Skip to main content

Nominal-π phasor, sending end, regulation, efficiency

Short answer

In nominal-π model, half shunt admittance Y/2 at each end of series impedance Z. Sending voltage: V_S=(1+ZY/2)V_R+Z I_R; current: I_S=Y(1+ZY/4)V_R+(1+ZY/2)I_R. Voltage regulation: %VR=(|V_S|/|1+ZY/2|−|V_R|)/|V_R|×100. Efficiency: η=P_R/(P_R+3|I_L|²R) where I_L=I_R+Y V_R/2.

Draw the phasor diagram for a nominal π circuit of a medium transmission line. Derive expressions for sending end voltage, current, voltage regulation and efficiency.

In the nominal-Π model of a medium line, the total series impedance Z=R+jXZ = R + jX is in the middle and half the shunt admittance, Y/2=jωC/2Y/2 = j\omega C/2, is connected at each end.

 IS       IL    Z = R + jX        IR
 o-->--+-----[ R ]--[ jX ]-----+-->--o
       |                       |
 VS  [Y/2] Ic1           Ic2 [Y/2]  VR
       |                       |
 o-----+-----------------------+-----o

Phasor diagram (lagging load, VRV_R as reference)

Construction:

  1. Draw VRV_R along the reference axis and IRI_R lagging by ϕR\phi_R.
  2. IC2=jωC2VRI_{C2} = j\frac{\omega C}{2}V_R leads VRV_R by 90°.
  3. IL=IR+IC2I_L = I_R + I_{C2}.
  4. From the tip of VRV_R add ILRI_L R (parallel to ILI_L) and ILXI_L X (90° ahead of ILI_L) to get VSV_S.
  5. IC1=jωC2VSI_{C1} = j\frac{\omega C}{2}V_S leads VSV_S by 90°; IS=IL+IC1I_S = I_L + I_{C1}.
          IC2 ^           IL.X  /VS
              |              | /
              |              |/ IL.R
   O-----------------------> VR
    \ \  phiR
     \  \ IL     (IS = IL + IC1,
      v   v       IC1 is 90 deg ahead of VS)
      IR

Sending-end voltage

IL=IR+Y2VRVS=VR+ZIL=VR+Z(IR+Y2VR)VS=(1+ZY2)VR+ZIR\begin{aligned} I_L &= I_R + \frac{Y}{2}V_R \\ V_S &= V_R + Z I_L = V_R + Z\left(I_R + \frac{Y}{2}V_R\right) \\ V_S &= \left(1 + \frac{ZY}{2}\right)V_R + Z I_R \end{aligned}

Sending-end current

IS=IL+Y2VS=IR+Y2VR+Y2[(1+ZY2)VR+ZIR]IS=Y(1+ZY4)VR+(1+ZY2)IR\begin{aligned} I_S &= I_L + \frac{Y}{2}V_S \\ &= I_R + \frac{Y}{2}V_R + \frac{Y}{2}\left[\left(1 + \frac{ZY}{2}\right)V_R + ZI_R\right] \\ I_S &= Y\left(1 + \frac{ZY}{4}\right)V_R + \left(1 + \frac{ZY}{2}\right)I_R \end{aligned}

So A=D=1+ZY/2A = D = 1 + ZY/2, B=ZB = Z, C=Y(1+ZY/4)C = Y(1 + ZY/4).

Voltage regulation

At no load (IR=0I_R = 0), VR(NL)=VS/AV_{R(NL)} = V_S/A. Hence

% VR=∣VS∣/∣A∣−∣VR∣∣VR∣×100=∣VS∣−∣1+ZY2∣∣VR∣∣1+ZY2∣∣VR∣×100\%\,\text{VR} = \frac{|V_S|/|A| - |V_R|}{|V_R|}\times 100 = \frac{\left|V_S\right| - \left|1 + \frac{ZY}{2}\right|\left|V_R\right|}{\left|1 + \frac{ZY}{2}\right|\left|V_R\right|}\times100

Note: ∣VS∣/∣A∣|V_S|/|A| is used, not ∣VS∣|V_S|, because the shunt capacitance raises the no-load receiving voltage (Ferranti effect).

Efficiency

Only the series resistance carries loss, and it carries current ILI_L:

Ploss=3∣IL∣2Rη=PRPR+3∣IL∣2R×100=3∣VR∣∣IR∣cos⁡ϕR3∣VS∣∣IS∣cos⁡ϕS×100\begin{aligned} P_{loss} &= 3|I_L|^2 R \\ \eta &= \frac{P_R}{P_R + 3|I_L|^2R}\times100 = \frac{3|V_R||I_R|\cos\phi_R}{3|V_S||I_S|\cos\phi_S}\times100 \end{aligned}

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Power System Analysis I chapter 5 questions →