Skip to main content

Design: 120 m head plant, 33 kV

Short answer

Electrical output 15.215 MW, two 7.8 MW Francis units (15.6 MW), unit transformers, single busbar with bus section. LV 0.4 kV (250 kVA), MV 11 kV fault level ~126 MVA, HV 33 kV; generator CB rated 9.5 MVA.

A typical hydro power plant has the following details.

MonthDischarge (m³/s)Flow durationDischarge (m³/s)
Jan11.95Qmax (Q0)674.19 m³/s
Feb9.94Q25%48.90 m³/s
Mar9.20Q45%16.75 m³/s
Apr11.93Q65%9.34 m³/s
May8.48Q85%6.21 m³/s
Jun42.28Q95%4.38 m³/s
July120.98Qmin1.40 m³/s
Aug143.00
Sep110.27
Oct50.95
Nov24.66
Dec16.17
Turbine typeHead range (m)
Kaplan2 < H < 40
Francis10 < H < 350
Pelton50 < H < 1300
ParameterValue
Gross head120 m
Turbine efficiency90%
Generator efficiency97%
Transformer efficiency98%
Head loss5%
Riparian release10%
Generator sub-transient reactance15%
Transformer reactance12%
Transmission line inductance0.96 mH/km
Transmission line length20 km
Transmission voltage level33 kV
Generator voltage level11 kV
Transmission circuitSingle circuit

Design a power plant so as to obtain the following parameters i) Electrical power output taking design discharge as Q45% ii) Select the numbers of units and installed capacity with suitable reasons iii) Draw the single line diagram showing numbers of units, generators, power transformer, station transformer and diesel generator for black start iv) Select the type of turbine v) Select the type of busbar with suitable reasons vi) Calculate the MVA level of LV bus, MV bus and HV bus vii) Calculate the rating of CB to be used in your design. (Assume suitable data if required)

Assumptions: riparian release = 10% of the driest monthly mean flow; net head = gross head minus 5% loss; ρg=9.81\rho g = 9.81 kN/m³; generator power factor 0.85; base = 100 MVA. For fault levels the grid is taken as a source of 500 MVA at the 33 kV grid substation at the far end of the line (an assumed typical value, since grid data is not given).

i) Electrical power output at Q45%Q_{45\%}

Driest month = May (8.48 m³/s), so riparian release Qr=0.1×8.48=0.848Q_r = 0.1 \times 8.48 = 0.848 m³/s.

Qd=Q45%−Qr=16.75−0.848=15.902 m3/sHn=Hg(1−0.05)=120−6.00=114.00 mPhyd=ρgQdHn=9.81×15.902×114.00=17.784 MWPshaft=ηtPhyd=0.9×17.784=16.005 MWPgen=ηgPshaft=0.97×16.005=15.525 MWPout=ηtrPgen=0.98×15.525=15.215 MW\begin{aligned} Q_d &= Q_{45\%} - Q_r = 16.75 - 0.848 = 15.902\ \text{m}^3/\text{s} \\ H_n &= H_g(1 - 0.05) = 120 - 6.00 = 114.00\ \text{m} \\ P_{hyd} &= \rho g Q_d H_n = 9.81 \times 15.902 \times 114.00 = 17.784\ \text{MW} \\ P_{shaft} &= \eta_t P_{hyd} = 0.9 \times 17.784 = 16.005\ \text{MW} \\ P_{gen} &= \eta_g P_{shaft} = 0.97 \times 16.005 = 15.525\ \text{MW} \\ P_{out} &= \eta_{tr} P_{gen} = 0.98 \times 15.525 = 15.215\ \text{MW} \end{aligned}

Answer: generator output = 15.525 MW; power delivered to the 33 kV bus = 15.215 MW.

ii) Number of units and installed capacity

  • Choose 2 units. With a run-of-river flow that falls well below the design flow in the dry months, one unit can run near full load on half the design flow, so efficiency stays high in winter.
  • One unit can be maintained while the other runs, and two units keep the number of machines (and cost) low for a plant of this size.
  • Per unit: Q=15.902/2=7.951Q = 15.902/2 = 7.951 m³/s, generator output =15.525/2=7.763= 15.525/2 = 7.763 MW → rate each unit at 7.8 MW.
  • Generator rating: S=7.8/0.85=9.18S = 7.8/0.85 = 9.18 MVA → 9.5 MVA, 11 kV, 0.85 pf, 50 Hz.
  • Step-up transformer, one per unit: 10 MVA, 11/33 kV, YNd11 (next standard size above 9.5 MVA).

Answer: installed capacity = 2 × 7.8 MW = 15.6 MW.

iii) Single line diagram

 Line to grid  (33 kV, 20 km)
    |
  [CB]
    |
 ===+=====+=============+=== 33 kV bus
          |             |
        [CB]          [CB]
          |             |
        (T1)          (T2)
          |             |
        [CB]          [CB]
          |             |
 =========+====[BS]=====+=========+=== 11 kV bus
          |             |         |
        [GCB]         [GCB]     [CB]
          |             |         |
        (G1)          (G2)      (ST)
                                  |
 =================================+===+ 0.4 kV
                                      |
                                    [ACB]
                                      |
                                    (DG) black start
ItemRating
Generators G1–G29.5 MVA, 11 kV, 0.85 pf, 600 rpm, Xd′′X''_d = 15%
Step-up transformers T1–T210 MVA each, 11/33 kV, YNd11, XX = 12%
Station transformer ST250 kVA, 11/0.4 kV, Dyn11, 4.5% (aux load about 1.5% of capacity)
Diesel generator DG160 kVA, 0.4 kV (essential auxiliaries for black start)
Line33 kV, single circuit, 20 km to grid substation
NGRneutral grounding resistor (low-resistance earthing, one generator earthed at a time if preferred)

BS = bus section breaker, GCB = generator circuit breaker, ACB = air circuit breaker. Black start: with the grid dead, the DG energises the 0.4 kV auxiliary bus (governor oil pumps, cooling water, excitation field flashing, lighting and battery chargers), one unit is started and runs in island mode, and it then energises the step-up transformer and the line.

iv) Type of turbine

Hn=114.00H_n = 114.00 m lies in the Francis (10–350 m) and Pelton (50–1300 m) ranges, so the specific speed decides.

Shaft power per unit P=16.005/2=8002.7P = 16.005/2 = 8002.7 kW. With N=120f/pN = 120f/p (synchronous speeds) and Ns=NP/Hn5/4N_s = N\sqrt{P}/H_n^{5/4}, where Hn5/4=372.5H_n^{5/4} = 372.5:

NN (rpm)PolesNsN_s (metric, kW)
10006240.2
7508180.1
60010144.1
50012120.1
428.614102.9
3751690.1
333.31880.0

Usual ranges: Pelton about 10–30 per jet (multi-jet Ns=Ns,jetzN_s = N_{s,jet}\sqrt{z}), Francis about 60–300, Kaplan 300–1000.

Choose N=600N = 600 rpm (10 poles): Ns=144.1N_s = 144.1, which is in the medium Francis range. A Pelton would need many jets (single-jet NsN_s far above 30), and Kaplan is ruled out because the head is above 40 m.

Answer: 2 × vertical-axis Francis turbines, 600 rpm, about 8.00 MW each.

v) Type of bus bar

  • 11 kV: single bus bar with a bus-section breaker, units split between the two sections, so a bus fault or maintenance takes out only part of the plant.
  • 33 kV: single bus bar, sectionalised, with transformer bays and one line bay.

Reason: for a 15.6 MW plant a sectionalised single bus gives reasonable reliability at low cost; a double bus or main-and-transfer bus would cost much more and is normally used only for larger plants or grid substations.

vi) MVA level of LV, MV and HV buses

LV = 0.4 kV auxiliary bus, MV = 11 kV generator bus, HV = 33 kV switchyard bus. Station transformer 250 kVA, 4.5%.

Per-unit reactances on 100 MVA base:

xg=0.15×1009.5=1.5789 pu,xt=0.12×10010=1.2000 puXL=2πfLl=2π×50×0.96×10−3×20=6.032 Ωxl=XL×100332=6.03210.89=0.5539 pu,xgrid=100500=0.2000 puxgrid path=0.2000+0.5539=0.7539 pu\begin{aligned} x_g &= 0.15 \times \frac{100}{9.5} = 1.5789\ \text{pu}, \quad x_t = 0.12 \times \frac{100}{10} = 1.2000\ \text{pu} \\ X_L &= 2\pi f L l = 2\pi \times 50 \times 0.96\times10^{-3} \times 20 = 6.032\ \Omega \\ x_l &= \frac{X_L \times 100}{33^2} = \frac{6.032}{10.89} = 0.5539\ \text{pu}, \quad x_{grid} = \frac{100}{500} = 0.2000\ \text{pu} \\ x_{grid\ path} &= 0.2000 + 0.5539 = 0.7539\ \text{pu} \end{aligned} xst=0.045×1000.25=18.000 puSMV=2×100xg+100xt/2+xgrid path=126.7+73.9=200.5 MVASHV=100xg/2+xt/2+100xgrid path=72.0+132.6=204.6 MVAXMV=100200.5=0.4987 pu,SLV=1000.4987+18.000=5.41 MVA\begin{aligned} x_{st} &= 0.045 \times \frac{100}{0.25} = 18.000\ \text{pu} \\ S_{MV} &= 2 \times \frac{100}{x_g} + \frac{100}{x_t/2 + x_{grid\ path}} = 126.7 + 73.9 = 200.5\ \text{MVA} \\ S_{HV} &= \frac{100}{x_g/2 + x_t/2} + \frac{100}{x_{grid\ path}} = 72.0 + 132.6 = 204.6\ \text{MVA} \\ X_{MV} &= \frac{100}{200.5} = 0.4987\ \text{pu}, \quad S_{LV} = \frac{100}{0.4987 + 18.000} = 5.41\ \text{MVA} \end{aligned}
BusFault MVAIscI_{sc} (kA)
LV (0.4 kV)5.417.80
MV (11 kV)200.510.52
HV (33 kV)204.63.58

Answer: LV ≈ 5.41 MVA, MV ≈ 200.5 MVA, HV ≈ 204.6 MVA.

vii) Rating of circuit breakers

Breaking current from the bus fault levels above; making current = 2.55 × IscI_{sc} (IEC 62271-100); rated current ≥ 1.25 × full-load current.

BreakerFull-load currentRequired breakingSelected
GCB / 11 kV CBs499 A per generator200.5 MVA, 10.52 kA (make 26.8 kA)12 kV, 630 A, 25 kA VCB
HV CB (33 kV)350 A total204.6 MVA, 3.58 kA (make 9.1 kA)36 kV, 630 A, 16 kA SF6
LV ACB (0.4 kV)361 A (station tr.)5.41 MVA, 7.80 kA (make 13.3 kA*)415 V, 630 A, 25 kA ACB

*At 0.4 kV the making current uses the IEC 60947-2 factor n = 1.7 for this fault current.

Answer: 11 kV GCB: 12 kV, 630 A, 25 kA; 33 kV CB: 36 kV, 630 A, 16 kA; 0.4 kV ACB: 630 A, 25 kA.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Power Plant Design chapter 4 questions →