Chapter 2 · 5 hours
Solids- Water –Air Relations and Index properties of soils
IOE past exam questions
Past questions and answers
24 questions set from this chapter, 5 of them more than once; 2 are most repeated (set, or a close variant set, in 3 or more exams). Most repeated first.
- Most repeated · 5 of 12 exams
- Asked 5 times
- 2079 Asoj · 2 marks
- 2075 Bhadra · 3 marks
- 2075 Baisakh · 2 marks
- 2076 Baisakh · 2 marks
- 2073 Magh · 3 marks
Draw the stress-strain curves (graph) for soil at different consistency states.
Answer
Soil changes its state with water content: solid, semi-solid, plastic and liquid, separated by the shrinkage limit (), plastic limit () and liquid limit (). The stress-strain behaviour differs in each state.
Stress-strain curves
Stress
| ___ Solid (brittle, peak
| /\ then sudden drop)
| / \______ Semi-solid
| / ______ Plastic (yields,
| / __/ strain hardens
|/ _/ ......... Liquid (no
|/.-' stress, flows)
+-------------------- Strain
| State | Water content | Behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| Solid | Very high strength, brittle, small strain at failure, no volume change on drying | |
| Semi-solid | Stiff, brittle, crumbles when moulded, volume decreases when dried | |
| Plastic | Can be moulded without cracking; strength falls and strain at failure rises; ductile (plastic flow) | |
| Liquid | Flows like a viscous fluid; almost zero shear strength; stress is nearly independent of strain |
As water content rises, the peak strength drops and the strain at failure increases. The brittle curve has a sharp peak with a post-peak drop, the plastic curve rises gradually and levels off, and the liquid curve lies on the strain axis.
- Most repeated · 4 of 12 exams
- Asked 4 times
- 2079 Jestha · 2+2 marks
- 2078 Poush · 4 marks
- 2075 Baisakh · 1 mark
- 2075 Bhadra · 2 marks
What are the index properties and engineering properties of soil? How does an index property differ from an engineering property? Why is it necessary to determine the index properties (which property is significant for identification and classification)?
Answer
Index properties
Index properties are simple properties of soil that help to identify and classify it and indicate its probable engineering behaviour. They do not give design values directly.
- Soil grain properties: specific gravity, particle size and shape, grain size distribution.
- Soil mass properties: water content, unit weight, void ratio, porosity, relative density, consistency limits, consistency index, sensitivity, activity.
Engineering properties
These are the properties that control the behaviour of soil in design:
- Permeability, compressibility (consolidation), shear strength, compaction characteristics (MDD, OMC), bearing capacity, swelling.
Difference
| Index property | Engineering property |
|---|---|
| Used for identification and classification | Used directly in design |
| Easy, quick and cheap tests | Complex, costly, time-consuming tests |
| Disturbed samples can often be used | Undisturbed samples usually required |
| Examples: , , , grain size | Examples: , , , |
Why index properties are determined
- To identify and classify soil quickly (USCS, IS, AASHTO).
- To judge the soil's probable behaviour (for example high means high compressibility).
- To compare soils from different sites and check uniformity along a site.
- To use empirical correlations for preliminary design (e.g. ).
- To check quality control on fill.
For coarse-grained soils, grain size distribution is the most significant index property; for fine-grained soils, plasticity (consistency limits) is the most significant.
- Asked 2 times
- 2076 Baisakh · 1 mark
- 2075 Baisakh · 2 marks
Name the index tests that are generally carried out to find the index properties of individual soil grains and of the soil mass as a whole.
Answer
Tests for individual soil grains
- Specific gravity test (pycnometer or density bottle).
- Particle size analysis (sieve analysis for coarse grains, hydrometer or pipette analysis for fine grains).
- Particle shape and mineralogical tests (visual, microscope).
Tests for the soil mass as a whole
- Water content (oven drying, calcium carbide, sand bath, pycnometer).
- Unit weight / density (core cutter, sand replacement, water displacement method).
- Void ratio, porosity and degree of saturation (calculated from the above).
- Relative density test for sands (maximum and minimum density).
- Consistency limits (Atterberg limits): liquid limit (Casagrande/cone penetrometer), plastic limit, shrinkage limit.
- Sensitivity (unconfined compression) and field tests such as dilatancy and toughness.
- Asked 2 times
- 2075 Bhadra · 3 marks
- 2076 Baisakh · 2 marks
Draw the phase diagram of soil for saturated, partially saturated and dry conditions.
Answer
A phase diagram shows soil as separate blocks of solids, water and air, with volumes on the left and weights on the right. Here are volumes of solids, water and air, is the void volume, and are the weights (air weight is taken as zero).
Partially saturated
Volume Weight
+--------+ --- +----------+
| Air | Va | 0 |
|--------| | Vv |----------|
| Water | Vw | Ww |
|--------| --- |----------| W
| Solids | Vs | Ws |
+--------+ +----------+
V=Vs+Vw+Va W=Ws+Ww
Fully saturated (, )
+--------+ --- +----------+
| Water | Vw=Vv | Ww |
|--------| --- |----------|
| Solids | Vs | Ws |
+--------+ +----------+
Dry (, , )
+--------+ --- +----------+
| Air | Va=Vv | 0 |
|--------| --- |----------|
| Solids | Vs | Ws = W |
+--------+ +----------+
- Asked 2 times
- 2078 Poush · 4 marks
- 2077 Chaitra · 2 marks
Describe the different field methods used to determine the in-situ (dry) density / dry unit weight of soil, based on site conditions.
Answer
The in-situ density is found by taking out a known volume of soil from the ground and weighing it; the water content gives the dry density, . The method depends on the soil type.
1. Core cutter method (IS 2720 Part 29)
Used for soft to medium cohesive soils that stand without crumbling. A steel cylinder (usually 100 mm dia, 130 mm high) is driven into the ground with a dolly and rammer, dug out with the soil inside, trimmed and weighed. Volume = volume of the cutter, so .
2. Sand replacement method (IS 2720 Part 28)
Used for gravelly and sandy soils, hard clay, or where the core cutter cannot be used. A hole is dug, the soil is weighed, and the hole volume is found by filling it with calibrated dry sand (Ottawa/ standard sand) from a pouring cylinder.
3. Water displacement method
Used for soils with irregular holes. The hole is lined with a thin rubber balloon or plastic sheet and filled with a measured volume of water to find the volume.
4. Rubber balloon method
A balloon density apparatus measures the volume of the hole directly from the water pressed into the balloon.
5. Nuclear density gauge
Gives density and water content quickly by gamma-ray backscatter; used for rapid quality control of compaction.
6. Wax-coated lump (paraffin) method
For cohesive, hard lumps of irregular shape; the lump is coated with wax and its volume found by water displacement.
Selection: core cutter for soft fine-grained soil, sand replacement for coarse soils, and nuclear gauge for large-scale quick control.
- 2079 Asoj · 3 marks
How do the engineering properties of soil differ from index properties? Mention different index tests done for coarse and fine grained soils.
Answer
Difference
| Engineering properties | Index properties |
|---|---|
| Needed directly for design (strength, settlement, flow) | Used for identification and classification |
| Examples: , , , , | Examples: , , , grain size, , |
| Complex and costly tests, undisturbed samples | Simple, cheap tests, disturbed samples often enough |
| Depend on the structure and stress state | Depend mostly on composition |
Index tests
- Coarse-grained soils: sieve analysis (grain size distribution, , ), specific gravity, relative density (maximum and minimum density), in-situ density, water content, particle shape.
- Fine-grained soils: hydrometer/pipette analysis, Atterberg limits (liquid limit, plastic limit, shrinkage limit), plasticity index, consistency index, activity, sensitivity, and field tests (dilatancy, dry strength, toughness).
- 2078 Baisakh · 2 marks
Sketch the phase diagram for a soil and indicate the volumes and weights of the phases on it. Define void ratio and degree of saturation.
Answer
Phase diagram
Volume Weight
+---------+ --- +-----------+
| Air | Va | 0 |
|---------| | Vv |-----------|
| Water | Vw | Ww |
|---------| --- |-----------| W
| Solids | Vs | Ws |
+---------+ +-----------+
V = Vs+Vw+Va W = Ws+Ww
Here is the volume of voids; and are weights of water and solids.
Void ratio ()
The ratio of the volume of voids to the volume of solids:
It is a ratio (no unit) and can be more than 1 (for example in soft clays).
Degree of saturation ()
The ratio of the volume of water to the volume of voids, in percent:
for dry soil and for fully saturated soil.
- 2077 Chaitra · 2 marks
Draw phase diagrams for a dry soil sample and a saturated soil sample before and after the compaction and consolidation processes, respectively.
Answer
Compaction reduces air voids by mechanical energy (no water leaves); consolidation reduces voids by squeezing water out of saturated soil under a sustained load. Solids volume is constant in both.
Dry soil before and after compaction
Before After (V reduced)
+------+ +------+
| Air | | Air | (less)
| | +------+
| | |Solids| Vs same
+------+ +------+
|Solids|
+------+
Air volume decreases, so the void ratio and total volume decrease; is unchanged.
Saturated soil before and after consolidation
Before After (V reduced)
+------+ +------+
|Water | |Water | (less)
| | +------+
| | |Solids| Vs same
+------+ +------+
|Solids|
+------+
Water is expelled from the voids, so and decrease, remains 100% and decreases.
In both cases the void ratio falls and dry unit weight rises.
- 2076 Baisakh · 2 marks
Name the different types of unit weights used in soil mechanics and express them in terms of weights and volumes of soil solid, void water and void air.
Answer
Symbols: = weight of solids, = weight of water, , = volume of solids, = volume of water, = volume of air, , .
| Unit weight | Meaning | Expression |
|---|---|---|
| Bulk (moist/total) unit weight | Total weight per unit total volume | |
| Dry unit weight | Weight of solids per unit total volume | |
| Saturated unit weight | Weight per unit volume when | with |
| Submerged (buoyant) unit weight | Effective weight under water | |
| Unit weight of solids | Weight of solids per volume of solids | |
| Unit weight of water | Weight of water per volume of water | (9.81 kN/m³) |
- 2078 Chaitra · 4 marks
Describe toughness index, coefficient of curvature, activity of soil and air content.
Answer
Toughness index ()
The ratio of plasticity index to flow index:
It measures the shear strength of soil at the plastic limit. Typical values are 0 to 3; low values mean the soil is friable and has low toughness.
Coefficient of curvature ()
A shape parameter of the grain size curve:
A well-graded gravel or sand has between 1 and 3.
Activity of soil ()
The ratio of the plasticity index to the percent of clay-size particles (< 2 micron):
inactive (kaolinite), 0.75 - 1.25 normal (illite), active (montmorillonite). It indicates the swelling potential.
Air content ()
The ratio of volume of air to total volume of the soil:
Also , where is porosity and is the degree of saturation.
- 2073 Bhadra · 2 marks
Define thixotropy and flow index.
Answer
Thixotropy
Thixotropy is the property of some clay soils to lose strength when disturbed (remoulded) at constant water content, and regain it with time on standing at rest. The regain is caused by reorientation of water molecules and particles in the adsorbed layer. Example: pile driving in clay softens the soil, then the strength returns after some days (pile "freeze").
Flow index ()
The slope of the flow curve, i.e. the line of water content against log of number of blows in the liquid limit test. It is the change in water content per one log cycle of blows:
A high flow index means the shear strength falls quickly with increase in water content.
- 2079 Jestha · 1+5 marks
Define relative consistency. The values of liquid limit, plastic limit and shrinkage limit of a soil were reported as follows: , , . If a sample of this soil at liquid limit has a volume of 40 cc and its volume measured at shrinkage limit was 23.5 cc, determine the specific gravity of the solids. What is its shrinkage ratio? Also draw the phase diagram of the soil at liquid limit and at shrinkage limit as per the given values.
Answer
Relative consistency
The relative consistency (consistency index) is the ratio of the difference between the liquid limit and the natural water content to the plasticity index:
means the soil is at the plastic limit (stiff), and means it is at the liquid limit (very soft).
Given
, , , cc, cc, .
Mass of solids
The soil is saturated at the liquid limit and at the shrinkage limit, and the volume of solids is the same. The volume difference is the volume of water lost between and (density of water 1 g/cc):
Specific gravity
At the shrinkage limit the soil is just saturated: .
Shrinkage ratio
Answer: , .
Phase diagrams (per the sample)
At liquid limit At shrinkage limit
V = 40 cc V = 23.5 cc
+--------+ +--------+
| Water | 24.75 cc | Water | 8.25 cc
| 24.75 g| | 8.25 g |
|--------| |--------|
| Solids | 15.25 cc | Solids | 15.25 cc
| 41.25 g| | 41.25 g|
+--------+ +--------+
W = 66.0 g W = 49.5 g
S = 100%, Va = 0 S = 100%, Va = 0
Weights of water: g at the liquid limit and g at the shrinkage limit. At both limits there is no air.
- 2079 Asoj · 3 marks
The in-situ field unit weight and water content of soil are 18 kN/m³ and 10% respectively. Soil excavated from this in-situ site is used for embankment construction. The dry unit weight and water content of the soil at the compaction site are 19 kN/m³ and 18% respectively. Determine the amount of soil to be excavated for 1 m³ of compaction. Assume necessary conditions.
Answer
Given
In-situ: kN/m³, . Compacted fill: kN/m³, , volume = 1 m³. Take kN/m³ (it cancels in the answer).
Solution
Dry unit weight at the excavation site:
Weight of dry soil (solids) needed in 1 m³ of embankment:
The solids weight is the same at the borrow site and in the fill, so the volume to excavate is:
Answer: about 1.16 m³ of soil must be excavated for each 1 m³ of compacted fill.
Assumption: no loss of soil during hauling and spreading.
- 2078 Chaitra · 4 marks
A mass of moist soil is 20 kg and its volume is 0.011 m³. After oven drying, the mass reduces to 16.5 kg. Assume G = 2.70. Determine water content, dry density, degree of saturation and porosity.
Answer
Given
kg, m³, dry mass kg, , kg/m³.
Solution
Mass of water: kg.
Water content
Dry density
Void ratio (from ):
Degree of saturation
Porosity
Answer: , kg/m³, , .
- 2078 Poush · 4 marks
An undisturbed sample of saturated clay has a volume of 20 cc and weighs 38 gm. After oven drying the weight reduces to 28 gm. Calculate the void ratio and specific gravity.
Answer
Given
cc, g, dry weight g, .
Solution
Weight (and volume) of water: g, so cc (taking g/cc).
As the clay is saturated, cc, so:
Check: , and (agrees).
Answer: void ratio , specific gravity .
- 2078 Poush · 4 marks
You are appointed as a supervisor for a road construction project. During the construction process, the contractor compacted the base course of the road and the average water content for the test samples was found to be 15%, the specific gravity of soil grains = 2.7 and unit weight of soil = 18 kN/m³. The specification requires that void ratio < 0.75. If you have to pass the bill for that task according to the specification, would you pass the bill for that work?
Answer
Given
, , kN/m³, specified . Take kN/m³.
Solution
Dry unit weight:
Void ratio from :
Since , the compaction meets the specification.
Decision: pass the bill for this base course work. (A check using the average of several samples is taken as given; individual samples should also be checked.)
- 2078 Baisakh · 6 marks
A field density test was conducted by core cutter method and the following data was obtained.
Weight of empty core-cutter = 22.80 N
Weight of soil and core-cutter = 50.05 N
Inside diameter of the core-cutter = 90.0 mm
Height of core-cutter = 180.0 mm
Weight of wet sample for moisture determination = 0.5405 N
Weight of oven-dry sample = 0.5112 N
Specific gravity of soil grains = 2.72
Determine (i) dry density, (ii) void ratio, and (iii) degree of saturation.
Answer
Given
Empty cutter 22.80 N; soil + cutter 50.05 N; mm; mm; ; moisture sample 0.5405 N wet and 0.5112 N dry. kN/m³.
Volume and bulk unit weight
Water content
(i) Dry density
(ii) Void ratio
(iii) Degree of saturation
Answer: kN/m³ ( kg/m³), , .
- 2077 Chaitra · 4 marks
Dry sand is poured into a cylindrical container (internal diameter 0.2 m and height 0.2 m) and just filled up to its top. The weight of the dry sand in the container is found to be 10 kg. By adding water, this dry sand sample is fully saturated with water. Let the void ratio of this sand sample be 0.54, which remains constant throughout the saturation process. Taking the specific gravity of soil solids as 2.65, find: (i) the amount of water needed to fully saturate the dry sand sample and its water content at full saturation; (ii) the amount of water to be added to the dry sand sample to achieve 80% degree of saturation. Mention the assumed condition if any.
Answer
Given
Container: m, m, so m³. Dry sand kg, , (constant). kg/m³.
Assumption: the stated void ratio of 0.54 is used directly with the given mass of sand; the mass of solids fixes , and the void volume is . (Using the container volume with would give a slightly different mass of 10.8 kg, so the data are only approximately consistent.)
Volume of solids
(i) Water to saturate the sand
Water needed kg (litres).
Water content at saturation:
(ii) Water for 80% saturation
So 1.63 litres of water must be added to the dry sand.
Answer: (i) 2.04 kg of water, ; (ii) 1.63 kg (litres) of water.
- 2077 Chaitra · 6 marks
A soil in the borrow pit is at a dry density of 17 kN/m³ with a moisture content of 10%. The soil is excavated from this pit and compacted in an embankment to a dry density of 18 kN/m³ with a moisture content of 15%. Compute the quantity of soil to be excavated from the borrow pit and the amount of water to be added for 100 m³ of compacted soil in the embankment.
Answer
Given
Borrow pit: kN/m³, . Embankment: kN/m³, , m³. kN/m³.
Dry weight of soil needed
Volume to be excavated
The same solids weight must come from the pit:
Water to be added
In volume: m³ litres.
Answer: excavate 105.9 m³ from the borrow pit; add 90 kN (about 9.17 m³ or 9170 litres) of water.
- 2075 Baisakh · 3 marks
An embankment is made by compacting the soil. For compaction, 1,00,000 m³ of the soil is excavated from a borrow pit having void ratio equal to 0.8. Calculate the volume of the embankment if its void ratio after compaction is 0.6.
Answer
Principle
Compaction does not change the volume of solids. Only the void volume is reduced.
Given
Borrow pit: m³, . Embankment: .
Solution
Volume of the compacted embankment:
Answer: volume of embankment m³ (about 11,111 m³ less than excavated).
- 2073 Magh · 5 marks
An embankment of 1,00,000 m³ volume has to be constructed by compacting the soil brought from an excavation site. After compaction, the dry unit weight of the compacted soil (embankment) will be 16 kN/m³. Also, the bulk unit weight and water content of the soil at the excavation site are 12 kN/m³ and 15%, respectively. Find the volume and weight of soil to be excavated from the excavation site. Take specific gravity of soil solid as 2.70.
Answer
Given
Embankment: m³, kN/m³. Excavation site: kN/m³, , .
Dry weight needed in the embankment
Dry unit weight at the excavation site
Volume to be excavated
Weight of soil to be excavated (moist)
(check: kN)
The specific gravity is not needed for this answer; it would only be used to find void ratios.
Answer: volume m³; weight kN (dry weight kN).
- 2074 Bhadra · 8 marks
A relative density test conducted on a sandy soil obtained the following results: maximum void ratio = 1.25, minimum void ratio = 0.45, relative density = 40% and G = 2.65. Find the dry density of the soil in the present state. If a 3 m thickness of this stratum is densified to a relative density of 60%, how much will the soil reduce in thickness? What will be the new density in dry and saturated conditions?
Answer
Given
, , , , m, kN/m³.
1. Present state
2. After densifying to
Reduction in thickness (volume of solids constant, area constant):
New thickness m.
3. New unit weights
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Present | 0.93 |
| Present | 13.47 kN/m³ |
| Reduction in thickness | 0.249 m (about 249 mm) |
| New | 14.69 kN/m³ |
| New | 18.95 kN/m³ |
Answer: present kN/m³; thickness reduces by 0.249 m; new kN/m³ and kN/m³.
- 2076 Baisakh · 3 marks
From the pycnometer test, the specific gravity of soil solid of the soil specimen is found to be 2.65. Also, the dry unit weight of this soil specimen is found to be 15 kN/m³. If one cubic meter of this soil specimen weighs 18 kN/m³, determine (i) water content, (ii) degree of saturation, and (iii) submerged unit weight of this soil specimen.
Answer
Given
, kN/m³, kN/m³, kN/m³.
(i) Water content
(ii) Degree of saturation
Void ratio:
(iii) Submerged unit weight
Imagine the soil saturated at the same void ratio:
Answer: , , kN/m³.
- 2073 Bhadra · 6 marks
A sample of saturated clay has a volume of 97 cm³ and mass of 202 gm. When completely dried, its volume is 87 cm³ and mass of 167 gm. Determine: (i) initial water content, (ii) specific gravity of soil solids, (iii) shrinkage limit.
Answer
Given
Initial: cm³, g. Dry: cm³, g. g/cm³.
(i) Initial water content
(ii) Specific gravity
The sample is saturated initially, so :
(iii) Shrinkage limit
So .
Check using the dry volume: cm³ (agrees).
Answer: (i) , (ii) , (iii) shrinkage limit .
Questions from Old Question Collection (CE 552) (IOE BCE Soil Mechanics (CE552) papers from 2073 Bhadra to 2079 Asoj). Answers are written for this site; check them against your class notes.
Chapter titles and hours from the IOE syllabus ↗