Chapter 2 · 4 hours
Working Stress Method of Design
IOE past exam questions
Past questions and answers
18 questions set from this chapter. Most repeated first.
- 2082 Bhadra · 8 marks
A rectangular beam with 350 mm width and 650 mm effective depth is reinforced with five 25 mm diameter tension bars. Due to accidental reason the beam has to resist a service load moment of 150 kNm. Determine whether the beam is safe or not. Considering the safety of the beam, also determine the stress developed in concrete and steel at the state of failure as per WSM. Use M25 concrete and Fe415 steel.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, 5-25 mm dia, mm, kN·m. M25: N/mm; Fe415: N/mm; .
Step 1: Constants (M25: , Fe415: N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 230 N/mm.
Safety check: kN·m 150 kN·m. The beam is safe.
Stresses at the service moment of 150 kN·m (neutral axis mm):
Stresses at the limiting (failure) state as per WSM: the section is over-reinforced, so concrete reaches its permissible stress first. At this state concrete stress N/mm and steel stress N/mm (less than 230 N/mm).
Answer: Beam is safe ( kN·m kN·m). At failure state: N/mm, N/mm. (At 150 kN·m: , N/mm.)
- 2081 Bhadra · 8 marks
A rectangular beam is 300 mm wide and has 550 mm effective depth. It is reinforced with 4 bars of 12 mm diameter. Determine the moment of resistance using the working stress method of analysis. Use M20 concrete and Fe415 steel.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, 4-12 mm dia, mm. M20: N/mm, ; Fe415: N/mm.
Step 1: Constants (M20: , Fe415: N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is under-reinforced: steel reaches N/mm first, so steel governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in concrete at this moment: N/mm 7 N/mm (safe).
Answer: kN·m (under-reinforced section).
- 2081 Baisakh · 9 marks
A rectangular beam of size 300 mm x 550 mm effective depth is reinforced with 4-16 mm diameter tension bars. Determine the stress induced in the top compression fibre of the concrete and tension steel when it is subjected to a moment of 50 kN-m. Take M20 concrete and Fe 415 grade steel with the permissible stress in concrete and steel not exceeding 5 MPa and 140 MPa respectively.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, 4-16 mm dia, mm, kN·m. Permissible: , N/mm. For M20, modular ratio (IS 456, Annex B-1.3).
Step 1: Neutral axis (elastic cracked section)
Step 2: Lever arm
Step 3: Stresses
Both are less than the permissible values (5 and 140 N/mm), so the section is safe.
Answer: stress in extreme compression concrete N/mm; stress in tension steel N/mm.
- 2080 Bhadra · 8 marks
Determine the area of steel required and the moment of resistance for a RC beam 250 mm x 450 mm. Consider M15 grade concrete and mild steel. Use the working stress method.
Answer
Assumption: the section is given as , so mm and effective depth mm. For M15 concrete N/mm, ; for mild steel N/mm.
Step 1: Balanced section constants
Step 2: Moment of resistance (balanced section, maximum for singly reinforced)
Step 3: Area of steel
Minimum steel check (IS 456, cl. 26.5.1.1): mm , OK.
Provide 4-16 mm dia bars ( mm).
Answer: mm (say 4-16 mm bars) and kN·m.
- 2080 Baisakh · 8 marks
An RC beam 230 mm wide and 400 mm deep (effective depth of 380 mm with area of steel 580 mm) has permissible stress in concrete and steel 5 N/mm and 140 N/mm respectively. Find the moment of resistance of the section and actual stresses in concrete and steel.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, mm, , N/mm (M15 concrete, mild steel), .
Step 1: Constants (, N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is under-reinforced: steel reaches N/mm first, so steel governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in concrete at this moment: N/mm 5 N/mm (safe).
Actual stresses at : concrete N/mm, steel N/mm.
Answer: kN·m; actual stresses are N/mm and N/mm.
- 2079 Bhadra · 6 marks
Derive equations for bending moment carrying capacity of a double reinforced rectangular section using assumptions for working stress method given by IS 456:2000.
Answer
Assumptions (IS 456:2000, Annex B-1.2)
- Plane sections remain plane after bending.
- Concrete is elastic in compression and carries no tension.
- Perfect bond between steel and concrete; stress in steel modular ratio stress in surrounding concrete.
- For compression steel, effective modular ratio is (to allow for creep).
Notation: = width, = effective depth, = effective cover to compression steel, = depth of neutral axis, = tension steel, = compression steel, = modular ratio.
Section Strain Stresses/forces
+------+ |\ Cc (concrete)
d'| Asc | | \ x Cs (comp. steel)
| | -+--- NA
| | | /
| Ast | |/ T (tension steel)
+------+
Stress in concrete at the level of compression steel
By similar triangles of the strain diagram:
Stress in compression steel . The concrete displaced by the steel is allowed for by using as the equivalent concrete area.
Neutral axis (first moment of the equivalent area about the neutral axis is zero)
Moment of resistance
Taking moments about the tension steel, with concrete compression acting at from the top:
Substituting :
The first term is the moment of the singly reinforced (balanced) part when , and the second is the additional moment from the compression steel. The tension steel then follows from .
Checks: , and (190 N/mm for Fe415).
- 2079 Baisakh · 6 marks
Determine the moment of resistance of a RC rectangular beam of overall dimension 250 mm x 475 mm reinforced with 3-16 mm dia. bars in tension side. Use M20 concrete and Fe415 steel in working stress method.
Answer
Assumption: clear cover 25 mm, so mm. mm, mm.
Step 1: Constants (M20: , Fe415: N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 230 N/mm.
Answer: kN·m (over-reinforced, concrete governs).
- 2078 Bhadra · 8 marks
An R.C.C beam 25 cm wide and 60 cm deep has 4 bars of 20 mm dia. as tension reinforcement. The centre of bars being 5 cm above the bottom of the beam. Determine the uniformly distributed load the beam can carry over a simply supported effective span of 6.10 m. The permissible stresses in concrete and steel are taken as 7 MPa and 230 MPa respectively. Use modular ratio.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, mm, 4-20 mm dia, mm, span m, , N/mm, (modular ratio for M20).
Step 1: Constants (, N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 230 N/mm.
Step 4: Safe UDL on the simply supported span
Self weight kN/m, so the superimposed load is kN/m.
Answer: total safe UDL kN/m (including self weight), i.e. superimposed load kN/m.
- 2076 Chaitra · 2+2+4 marks
Describe the requirement of steel as reinforcement in RCC structure. Explain about moment of resistance of doubly reinforced section. Derive the formula.
Answer
Requirement of steel as reinforcement
Concrete is strong in compression but weak in tension (tensile strength is about 10% of compressive strength), so it cracks at low loads. Steel is therefore provided as reinforcement for the following reasons.
- Tension: steel carries the tensile force in beams, slabs, footings and ties, with concrete protecting it from corrosion and fire.
- Shear and torsion: stirrups and bent-up bars resist diagonal tension.
- Compression: longitudinal bars share the load in columns and raise capacity of beams (doubly reinforced section).
- Control of cracks and shrinkage: distribution and temperature steel limit crack width.
- Bond: steel has a similar coefficient of thermal expansion to concrete ( per C), and ribs/deformations give good bond.
- Ductility: steel gives warning before failure.
Moment of resistance of doubly reinforced section
A beam is doubly reinforced when the applied moment exceeds the balanced moment of the singly reinforced section, or when depth is restricted, or for reversal of moment. Compression steel is added at effective cover from the compression face. The moment of resistance is
where is the balanced-section moment and the additional moment taken by the compression steel and the additional tension steel.
Derivation
Assumptions (IS 456:2000, Annex B-1.2)
- Plane sections remain plane after bending.
- Concrete is elastic in compression and carries no tension.
- Perfect bond between steel and concrete; stress in steel modular ratio stress in surrounding concrete.
- For compression steel, effective modular ratio is (to allow for creep).
Notation: = width, = effective depth, = effective cover to compression steel, = depth of neutral axis, = tension steel, = compression steel, = modular ratio.
Section Strain Stresses/forces
+------+ |\ Cc (concrete)
d'| Asc | | \ x Cs (comp. steel)
| | -+--- NA
| | | /
| Ast | |/ T (tension steel)
+------+
Stress in concrete at the level of compression steel
By similar triangles of the strain diagram:
Stress in compression steel . The concrete displaced by the steel is allowed for by using as the equivalent concrete area.
Neutral axis (first moment of the equivalent area about the neutral axis is zero)
Moment of resistance
Taking moments about the tension steel, with concrete compression acting at from the top:
Substituting :
The first term is the moment of the singly reinforced (balanced) part when , and the second is the additional moment from the compression steel. The tension steel then follows from .
Checks: , and (190 N/mm for Fe415).
- 2076 Chaitra · 8 marks
Calculate the tensile reinforcement required for a rectangular RC beam of size 230 mm x 425 mm (overall) if it has to carry a moment of 64 kNm at service condition. Use M20 grade concrete mix and Fe500 grade steel in working stress method.
Answer
Assumptions: effective cover mm (top and bottom), so mm. M20: N/mm, . Fe500: N/mm (IS 456 Table 22 / Annex B). kN·m.
Step 1: Balanced moment of the singly reinforced section
Since kN·m, a singly reinforced section is not enough. The beam must be doubly reinforced.
Step 2: Moment shared by compression steel
Step 3: Compression steel
Depth of neutral axis (balanced) mm. Stress in concrete at the compression steel level:
Stress in compression steel N/mm, below the permissible value, OK.
Step 4: Tension steel
Answer: tensile reinforcement mm (e.g. 3-20 mm bars); compression reinforcement mm (e.g. 7-16 mm bars).
- 2076 Asoj · 8 marks
A rectangular RC beam of overall dimensions 300 mm x 500 mm is reinforced with 4-25 mm dia. bars in tension at an effective cover of 50 mm. The beam is simply supported over an effective span of 5 m. Calculate the total uniformly distributed load the beam can carry inclusive of its self weight. Use working stress method of design. Adopt M20 concrete and Fe415 grade (TOR) steel.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, effective cover 50 mm so mm, 4-25 mm dia, mm, m. M20: ; Fe415: N/mm; .
Step 1: Constants (M20: , Fe415: N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 230 N/mm.
Step 4: Total UDL
Self weight kN/m, so the external (superimposed) load is kN/m.
Answer: total UDL including self weight kN/m.
- 2075 Chaitra · 8 marks
A rectangular RC beam of overall dimensions 250 mm x 450 mm is reinforced with 4-16 mm dia. bars in tension at an effective cover of 40 mm. Calculate the moment of resistance of the beam using working stress method. Adopt M20 concrete and Fe415 grade steel.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, effective cover 40 mm so mm, 4-16 mm dia, mm. M20: , ; Fe415: N/mm.
Step 1: Constants (M20: , Fe415: N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 230 N/mm.
Answer: kN·m.
- 2075 Asoj · 7 marks
A rectangular R.C beam of size 230 x 350 mm overall is reinforced with 4-16 mm dia bars at tension zone in bottom. Determine the moment of resistance of that beam section if the permissible stresses in concrete and steel do not exceed 7.0 MPa and 140 MPa. Take nominal cover to re-bar as 25 mm and m = 13.33.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, nominal cover 25 mm, so mm. mm. , N/mm, .
Step 1: Constants (, N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 140 N/mm.
Answer: kN·m.
- 2074 Asoj · 6 marks
A simply supported rectangular RC beam of effective span 4.2 m and overall dimensions 230 mm x 450 mm is reinforced with 4-20 mm dia. bars in tension. Determine the moment of resistance. Take permissible stresses for M20 concrete and Fe415 grade steel.
Answer
Assumption: clear cover 25 mm, so mm. mm, mm. Permissible stresses: M20 N/mm, Fe415 N/mm, . (The span 4.2 m is not needed for .)
Step 1: Constants (M20: , Fe415: N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 230 N/mm.
Answer: kN·m.
- 2073 Shrawan · 6 marks
Find the moment of resistance of a RCC beam 250 mm wide and 500 mm effective depth if it is reinforced with 3-16 mm dia bars. The permissible stresses for concrete and steel are given as 7 MPa and 230 MPa. The value of modular ratio is taken as 13.33.
Answer
Given: mm, mm, 3-16 mm dia, mm, , N/mm, .
Step 1: Constants (, N/mm, )
Step 2: Actual neutral axis (taking moments of areas about the neutral axis, transformed section)
Since mm, the section is over-reinforced: concrete reaches N/mm first, so concrete governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Stress in steel at this moment: N/mm 230 N/mm.
Answer: kN·m.
- 2071 Chaitra · 4 marks
Using working stress method, design a rectangular section 300 mm width and 450 mm height carrying 30 kN/m load in the effective span 3.6 m. Use mild steel and M20 grade of concrete.
Answer
Assumptions: the 30 kN/m includes self weight; effective cover 50 mm so mm. M20: , ; mild steel: N/mm.
Step 1: Bending moment
Step 2: Balanced section capacity
So the section is under-reinforced and singly reinforced steel is enough.
Step 3: Area of steel
(Using of the balanced section is slightly conservative.) Minimum steel mm is satisfied.
Provide 5-16 mm dia bars, mm.
Check: neutral axis mm mm; kN·m 48.60 kN·m, safe.
Answer: Section 300 x 450 mm with 5-16 mm bars at effective depth 400 mm (plus nominal 2-10 mm hanger bars and stirrups).
- 2067 Asar (old course) · 12 marks
The moment of resistance of a rectangular reinforced concrete beam section having width b mm and overall depth D mm is . The stresses in the extreme fiber of the concrete and in the steel are not to exceed 7 N/mm and 140 N/mm respectively and the modular ratio equals 18.33. Determine the ratio between the depth of neutral axis from the compression fiber and the effective depth of the beam. The beam is reinforced for tension side only.
Answer
Given: (N·mm), , N/mm, , singly reinforced. Let .
Step 1: Balanced (critical) neutral axis
Balanced moment . The given moment is smaller than this, so the section is under-reinforced and steel stress governs ( N/mm), with the concrete stress below 7 N/mm.
Step 2: Equations for an under-reinforced section
Equilibrium of the transformed section: , so
Moment about the compression centroid:
Step 3: Solve for
Setting :
Solving numerically (trial and error): .
Check: concrete stress N/mm , consistent with an under-reinforced section; .
Answer: (neutral axis at about from the compression fibre).
- 2067 Asar (old course) · 8 marks
Determine the moment of resistance of the section shown below. Take = 7 N/mm and = 140 N/mm. [Figure: T-section with flange width 2000 mm, web width 250 mm, 3-20 mm dia. tension bars; dimensions 300 mm and 50 mm marked on the right side of the web (as printed, 300 mm is the depth and 50 mm the cover below the bars)]
Answer
Given (from figure): flange width mm, web width mm, 3-20 mm dia tension bars, mm. Overall depth 350 mm with 50 mm cover below bars, so effective depth mm. The flange thickness is not legible; assume mm (the result is the same for any found below). , N/mm, .
Step 1: Neutral axis (assuming it lies in the flange, so the section acts as a rectangle of width 2000 mm)
The assumption is correct (neutral axis is in the flange).
Step 2: Critical neutral axis
Since , the section is under-reinforced and steel governs.
Step 3: Moment of resistance
Concrete stress at this moment: N/mm , safe.
Answer: kN·m.
Questions from Old Question Collection (CE 702) (IOE exam papers from 2065 to 2082 (CE 702, BCE IV/I)) and Old Question Collection (CE 702) (4 IOE papers 2075 to 2079 (only 2079 Baisakh not already in the other file)). Answers are written for this site; check them against your class notes.
Chapter titles and hours from the IOE syllabus ↗