Skip to main content

Chapter 5 · 10 hours

Headworks of Run-of- River (RoR) Plants

IOE past exam questions

Past questions and answers

38 questions set from this chapter, 7 of them more than once; 5 are most repeated (set, or a close variant set, in 3 or more exams). Most repeated first.

  • Most repeated · 4 of 21 exams
  • 2076 Chaitra · 4+4 marks

Find out the dimension of a settling basin with turbulence flow for a high head hydropower plant, which utilizes a discharge of 60 m³/sec. The sediment particles coarser than 0.2 mm (fall velocity w = 1.5 cm/sec) have to be trapped in the basin. Draw plan and section showing major components and flushing arrangement, neat and proportionately.

Similar questions: Settling basin 50 m³/s, 0.2 mm (2080 Baishakh) · Settling basin 25 m³/s, 0.2 mm (2079 Baishakh) · Settling basin 40 m³/s, 0.15 mm (2070 Ashad)

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=60.0Q=60.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.20d\ge 0.20 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=1.50w=1.50 cm/s =0.0150=0.0150 m/s (given). Turbulence is considered. (A fall velocity of 1.5 cm/s is lower than the usual value for 0.2 mm sand, so the basin comes out long; the given value is used.)

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.20=19.68 cm/s=0.1968 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.20}=19.68\ \text{cm/s}=0.1968\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=6.0H=6.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=60.00.1968×6.0=50.82 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{60.0}{0.1968\times6.0}=50.82\ \text{m}

Provide n=3n=3 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=16.94b=B/n=16.94 m each, adopt 17.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1968×6.00.0150=78.7 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1968\times6.0}{0.0150}=78.7\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.19686.0=0.0106 m/sw′=0.0150−0.0106=0.0044 m/sL=vHw′=0.1968×6.00.0044=268.6 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1968}{\sqrt{6.0}}=0.0106\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0150-0.0106=0.0044\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1968\times6.0}{0.0044}=268.6\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.197 m/s
Settling depth HH6.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers3
Width of each chamber17.0 m
Length of settling zone270 m
Length/width ratio15.9
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈82620\approx 82620 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 3 chambers, each about 17.0 m wide x 270 m long x 6.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.197v=0.197 m/s.

  • Most repeated · 4 of 21 exams
  • 2080 Baishakh · 6+2 marks

Find out the dimension of a settling basin with turbulence flow for a high head hydropower plant, which utilizes a discharge of 50 m³/sec. The sediment particles coarser than 0.2 mm (w = 1.5 cm/sec) have to be trapped in the basin. Draw plan and section showing major components and flushing arrangement.

Similar questions: Settling basin 25 m³/s, 0.2 mm (2079 Baishakh) · Settling basin 60 m³/s, 0.2 mm, w = 1.5 cm/s (2076 Chaitra) · Settling basin 40 m³/s, 0.15 mm (2070 Ashad)

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=50.0Q=50.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.20d\ge 0.20 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=1.50w=1.50 cm/s =0.0150=0.0150 m/s (given). Turbulence is considered.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.20=19.68 cm/s=0.1968 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.20}=19.68\ \text{cm/s}=0.1968\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=6.0H=6.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=50.00.1968×6.0=42.35 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{50.0}{0.1968\times6.0}=42.35\ \text{m}

Provide n=3n=3 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=14.12b=B/n=14.12 m each, adopt 14.5 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1968×6.00.0150=78.7 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1968\times6.0}{0.0150}=78.7\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.19686.0=0.0106 m/sw′=0.0150−0.0106=0.0044 m/sL=vHw′=0.1968×6.00.0044=268.6 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1968}{\sqrt{6.0}}=0.0106\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0150-0.0106=0.0044\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1968\times6.0}{0.0044}=268.6\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.197 m/s
Settling depth HH6.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers3
Width of each chamber14.5 m
Length of settling zone270 m
Length/width ratio18.6
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈70470\approx 70470 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 3 chambers, each about 14.5 m wide x 270 m long x 6.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.197v=0.197 m/s.

  • Most repeated · 4 of 21 exams
  • 2070 Ashad · 3+3 marks

Find out the dimension of a settling basin with turbulent flow for a high-head hydropower plant, which utilizes a discharge of 40 m³/s. The sediment particles coarser than 0.15 mm (w = 1.5 cm/s) have to be trapped in the basin. Draw plan and sections (cross and longitudinal) showing major components and flushing arrangement.

Similar questions: Settling basin 50 m³/s, 0.2 mm (2080 Baishakh) · Settling basin 25 m³/s, 0.2 mm (2079 Baishakh) · Settling basin 60 m³/s, 0.2 mm, w = 1.5 cm/s (2076 Chaitra)

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=40.0Q=40.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.15d\ge 0.15 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=1.50w=1.50 cm/s =0.0150=0.0150 m/s (given). Turbulence is considered; both the plan and the sections are sketched.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.15=17.04 cm/s=0.1704 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.15}=17.04\ \text{cm/s}=0.1704\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=5.0H=5.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=40.00.1704×5.0=46.95 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{40.0}{0.1704\times5.0}=46.95\ \text{m}

Provide n=3n=3 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=15.65b=B/n=15.65 m each, adopt 16.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1704×5.00.0150=56.8 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1704\times5.0}{0.0150}=56.8\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.17045.0=0.0101 m/sw′=0.0150−0.0101=0.0049 m/sL=vHw′=0.1704×5.00.0049=172.5 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1704}{\sqrt{5.0}}=0.0101\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0150-0.0101=0.0049\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1704\times5.0}{0.0049}=172.5\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.170 m/s
Settling depth HH5.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers3
Width of each chamber16.0 m
Length of settling zone175 m
Length/width ratio10.9
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈42000\approx 42000 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 3 chambers, each about 16.0 m wide x 175 m long x 5.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.170v=0.170 m/s.

  • Most repeated · 4 of 21 exams
  • 2079 Baishakh · 6+2 marks

Find out the dimension of a settling basin with turbulence flow for a high head hydropower plant, which utilizes a discharge of 25 m³/sec. The sediment particles coarser than 0.2 mm (w = 1.5 cm/sec) have to be trapped in the basin. Draw plan and section showing major components and flushing arrangement.

Similar questions: Settling basin 50 m³/s, 0.2 mm (2080 Baishakh) · Settling basin 60 m³/s, 0.2 mm, w = 1.5 cm/s (2076 Chaitra) · Settling basin 40 m³/s, 0.15 mm (2070 Ashad)

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=25.0Q=25.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.20d\ge 0.20 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=1.50w=1.50 cm/s =0.0150=0.0150 m/s (given). Turbulence is considered.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.20=19.68 cm/s=0.1968 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.20}=19.68\ \text{cm/s}=0.1968\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=6.0H=6.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=25.00.1968×6.0=21.17 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{25.0}{0.1968\times6.0}=21.17\ \text{m}

Provide n=2n=2 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=10.59b=B/n=10.59 m each, adopt 11.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1968×6.00.0150=78.7 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1968\times6.0}{0.0150}=78.7\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.19686.0=0.0106 m/sw′=0.0150−0.0106=0.0044 m/sL=vHw′=0.1968×6.00.0044=268.6 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1968}{\sqrt{6.0}}=0.0106\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0150-0.0106=0.0044\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1968\times6.0}{0.0044}=268.6\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.197 m/s
Settling depth HH6.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers2
Width of each chamber11.0 m
Length of settling zone270 m
Length/width ratio24.5
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈35640\approx 35640 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 2 chambers, each about 11.0 m wide x 270 m long x 6.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.197v=0.197 m/s.

  • Most repeated · 3 of 21 exams
  • Asked 3 times
  • 2081 Bhadra · 3+2 marks
  • 2072 Chaitra · 6+6 marks
  • 2070 Ashad · 2+3 marks

Sketch a diagram (plan and section) showing the general arrangement of the components of a typical ROR plant headworks. List/describe the functional requirements of the headworks of an ROR plant (including the general requirements for optimum function in sediment loaded rivers).

Answer

General arrangement of a typical RoR headworks

PLAN
    river flow ==============================>
        left bank wall
   +-------------------------------------------+
   |  intake  | undersluice | weir (spillway)    |
   | (side)   |  (gates)    | ||||||||||||||||| |
   +----+-----+-------------+--------------------+
        |  gravel trap
        v                         fish ladder
   approach canal --> settling basin --> headrace
SECTION through weir, undersluice and intake
  pond level ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
        _____      weir crest  ______
  intake|rack |gate          /      \  stilling basin
  sill  |_____|-> canal     /        \____ apron
 ///////////  undersluice /////////  river bed
   (sill 1.0-1.5 m above bed)   flushing gate

Main components:

  • Diversion weir / barrage across the river to raise the water level for the intake and pass floods over its crest.
  • Undersluice (scouring sluice) at the intake side, with gates, to keep a flushing channel in front of the intake and to pass bed load.
  • Intake (side intake with trash rack and gate) on the outer bank, with its sill above the undersluice level.
  • Gravel trap and approach canal leading to the settling basin.
  • Fish ladder, river training works (guide bunds, flood walls), stilling basin and apron downstream of the weir.

Functional requirements of the headworks

  1. Safe passage of floods: the structure must be stable against the design flood (usually 1 in 100 year) and pass it with a limited afflux.
  2. Reliable diversion: divert the design discharge at all river stages, including low flow, with the intake always submerged.
  3. Minimum sediment entry: bed load must be kept out by a high sill, undersluice and gravel trap, and suspended load limited by the settling basin.
  4. Trash and floating debris control: trash rack, trash boom and log deflector.
  5. Stability and safety: weir safe against sliding, overturning and uplift; scour protected by cut-offs, aprons and a stilling basin.
  6. Environmental flow and fish passage as per law; minimum release downstream.
  7. Easy operation and maintenance with small head loss in the intake.

In rivers carrying a high sediment load

  • Place the intake at the outer bend, with the sill at least 1.0-1.5 m above the undersluice crest.
  • Make the undersluice large enough to give a flushing velocity that carries the boulders and gravel.
  • Provide a gravel trap and a settling basin with efficient flushing; allow frequent flushing of the pond in floods.
  • Use a flood-operation rule: close the intake during the high sediment-laden flood.
  • Asked 2 times
  • 2070 Chaitra · 3 marks
  • 2071 Chaitra · 3 marks

Explain the general requirements of a functional ROR headworks (what are the minimum performance standards of sound headworks?).

Answer

A RoR headworks takes the design discharge from the river without storage, so it must work reliably in both floods and low flows. The minimum standards of a sound headworks are:

  1. Stable and safe structure: designed for the 100-year flood (check for a higher flood); stable against sliding, overturning, uplift and piping; strong foundation with cut-offs and protection against scour.
  2. Adequate flood passage: spillway, undersluice and gates must pass the design flood with an acceptable afflux, without overtopping the banks or the flood walls.
  3. Dependable water supply: the intake must deliver the design discharge during the dry season, with the intake always submerged and no air entry or vortex; an environmental release is also kept in the river.
  4. Control of sediment: bed load is excluded by a high-level intake sill, an undersluice, a gravel trap and river training works; suspended sediment above the design size is removed in the settling basin. The sediment must not accumulate in front of the intake.
  5. Control of floating debris and trash: trash racks, trash booms, and a raking arrangement.
  6. Hydraulic efficiency: small head loss in the intake, a smooth flow transition and a low-turbulence approach.
  7. Operation and maintenance: gates and hoists easy to operate in floods, safe access, provision for flushing and inspection, and the arrangement for fish passage.
  8. Environment and economy: minimum impact on the river and fish, and a low cost relative to the energy produced.
  • Asked 2 times
  • 2082 Baishakh · 1+3 marks
  • 2079 Baishakh · 3+3 marks

What are the most commonly used intakes in Run-of-River projects in Nepal? What factors do you consider while selecting the site for intake location?

Answer

Intakes commonly used in RoR projects in Nepal

  1. Side intake: an opening in the river bank, with a trash rack and gate, built at the side of the weir and undersluice. It is the most common type in Nepal because the river carries a large bed load and the flow can be diverted with simple structures.
  2. Bottom (Tyrolean / drop) intake: a trench with a rack across the river bed in steep, boulder-carrying streams; water drops through the bars into a collection chamber (used in small hydropower and micro-hydro projects in the hills).
  3. Frontal intake: an opening at the front of the weir facing the flow (less common because it takes much bed load).

Factors for selecting the intake location

  • Outer (concave) bank of a stable river bend, where the secondary current moves bed load away from the intake; or a straight stable reach.
  • Stable river reach and good foundation: rock or firm soil; no active landslide or erosion.
  • Sufficient head and level to give gravity flow to the settling basin and headrace without long canals.
  • Away from sediment deposition zones, confluences of tributaries and high debris areas.
  • Good access for construction, operation and maintenance.
  • Cheap river training and weir construction: a narrow section where the weir is short, and enough space for the gravel trap and settling basin close by.
  • Flood safety: high flood level, minimal flood damage to the headworks and powerhouse.
  • Environmental and social: minimum effect on existing water users, fish and forest.
  • Asked 2 times
  • 2081 Baishakh · 4 marks
  • 2075 Chaitra · 1+2 marks

What do you mean by an intake? Write down its functions and sketch a generalized intake structure for a RoR diversion project.

Answer

Definition

An intake is the structure at the head of the water conductor system that withdraws the design discharge from the river (or reservoir) and admits it into the canal, tunnel or pipe in a controlled way.

Functions

  • Diverts the required discharge into the conveyance system at all river levels.
  • Controls the flow with a gate; shuts it off for inspection and during floods.
  • Excludes the bed load and the floating trash and debris through the sill, trash rack and trash boom.
  • Limits the entry of sediment and passes it to the gravel trap and settling basin.
  • Provides a smooth, low-loss transition and prevents air entry and vortices.

Sketch of a generalized RoR intake

PLAN
 river ===>  ||||||||||| weir
                 __________________________
 undersluice =|  trash rack  gate   |==> approach
 (flushing)   |_____________________|    canal

SECTION
  pond ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
        |    | rack   ____ gate
        |    |##   \ |    |
  sill  |____|##____\|____|=====> canal
  ///////////////// river bed (undersluice lower)

The sill of the intake is kept 1.0-1.5 m above the bed of the undersluice so that bed load cannot enter; the opening is sized so that the velocity at the trash rack is about 0.8-1.0 m/s.

  • Asked 2 times
  • 2074 Ashwin · 4 marks
  • 2071 Chaitra · 3 marks

Differentiate between pressurized and non-pressurized intakes in a RoR system.

Answer

A non-pressurized (free-surface) intake leads water into a canal or a free-surface tunnel, so the flow has a free surface. A pressurized intake leads water into a pressure tunnel or penstock, so the opening is fully submerged below the minimum water level and the conduit runs full.

PointNon-pressurized intakePressurized intake
Flow in the conduitOpen channel flow with a free surfaceClosed conduit under pressure
Typical useRoR plants taking water to a settling basin and open canal or free-flow tunnelStorage plants, or RoR with a pressure headrace tunnel
Intake openingOrifice/side opening with sill; may be partially submergedAlways fully submerged below minimum operating level
Vortex and air entryNot criticalCritical: needs enough submergence, anti-vortex devices and an air vent
Water level variationSmall (weir pond is nearly constant)Large (reservoir drawdown)
TransitionShort, to the canal widthLong bell-mouth from rectangular to circular tunnel
GateRegulating gate or stop-log at the entranceService gate (and emergency gate) in a gate shaft
Trash rackModerate size, can be raked from the topLarge, inclined, with trash-rake machine
SedimentGravel trap and settling basin followSediment excluded by a high sill
CostCheaper, simpleMore costly, since structure is deeper and heavier
  • Asked 2 times
  • 2076 Ashwin · 8+4 marks
  • 2075 Ashwin · 7 marks

Design a settling basin for a high head project in a river which utilizes 60 m³/s discharge and gross head of 300 m. The sediment particles larger than 0.15 mm (fall velocity = 1.5 cm/s) need to be trapped in the basin. Consider the effect of turbulence as well. Also draw the plan and section of the basin showing major components.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=60.0Q=60.0 m³/s and gross head 300 m (a high-head Pelton plant, so particles above 0.15 mm must be removed); particles of size d≥0.15d\ge 0.15 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=1.50w=1.50 cm/s =0.0150=0.0150 m/s (given). Turbulence is considered.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.15=17.04 cm/s=0.1704 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.15}=17.04\ \text{cm/s}=0.1704\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=6.0H=6.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=60.00.1704×6.0=58.68 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{60.0}{0.1704\times6.0}=58.68\ \text{m}

Provide n=3n=3 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=19.56b=B/n=19.56 m each, adopt 20.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1704×6.00.0150=68.2 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1704\times6.0}{0.0150}=68.2\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.17046.0=0.0092 m/sw′=0.0150−0.0092=0.0058 m/sL=vHw′=0.1704×6.00.0058=175.8 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1704}{\sqrt{6.0}}=0.0092\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0150-0.0092=0.0058\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1704\times6.0}{0.0058}=175.8\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.170 m/s
Settling depth HH6.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers3
Width of each chamber20.0 m
Length of settling zone180 m
Length/width ratio9.0
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈64800\approx 64800 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 3 chambers, each about 20.0 m wide x 180 m long x 6.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.170v=0.170 m/s.

  • Asked 2 times
  • 2074 Ashwin · 8 marks
  • 2073 Shrawan · 6 marks

With considering turbulent effect, design a settling basin to remove the sediment size greater than 0.3 mm diameter. Assume the design discharge of the basin is 8 m³/s and trap efficiency as 90%.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=8.0Q=8.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.30d\ge 0.30 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=4.00w=4.00 cm/s =0.0400=0.0400 m/s (assumed for 0.3 mm quartz at about 20 °C, after Rouse). The required trap efficiency is 90%, and turbulence is considered.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.30=24.10 cm/s=0.2410 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.30}=24.10\ \text{cm/s}=0.2410\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=3.5H=3.5 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=8.00.2410×3.5=9.48 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{8.0}{0.2410\times3.5}=9.48\ \text{m}

Provide n=2n=2 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=4.74b=B/n=4.74 m each, adopt 5.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.2410×3.50.0400=21.1 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.2410\times3.5}{0.0400}=21.1\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.24103.5=0.0170 m/sw′=0.0400−0.0170=0.0230 m/sL=vHw′=0.2410×3.50.0230=36.7 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.2410}{\sqrt{3.5}}=0.0170\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0400-0.0170=0.0230\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.2410\times3.5}{0.0230}=36.7\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

For a trap efficiency of 90% (Vetter's relation η=1−e−w′L/(vH)\eta=1-e^{-w'L/(vH)}) the length is multiplied by ln⁡11−η=2.303\ln\frac{1}{1-\eta}=2.303:

L=2.303×36.7=84.5 mL=2.303\times36.7=84.5\ \text{m}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.241 m/s
Settling depth HH3.5 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers2
Width of each chamber5.0 m
Length of settling zone85 m
Length/width ratio17.0
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈2975\approx 2975 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 2 chambers, each about 5.0 m wide x 85 m long x 3.5 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.241v=0.241 m/s.

  • 2080 Bhadra · 2+2+2 marks

Draw a neat sketch showing the typical arrangement of components of a headworks of a RoR hydropower project. Write down the importance of its intake. How do you decide the location of an intake in a river?

Answer

Typical arrangement of the headworks

PLAN
    river flow ==============================>
        left bank wall
   +-------------------------------------------+
   |  intake  | undersluice | weir (spillway)    |
   | (side)   |  (gates)    | ||||||||||||||||| |
   +----+-----+-------------+--------------------+
        |  gravel trap
        v                         fish ladder
   approach canal --> settling basin --> headrace
SECTION through weir, undersluice and intake
  pond level ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
        _____      weir crest  ______
  intake|rack |gate          /      \  stilling basin
  sill  |_____|-> canal     /        \____ apron
 ///////////  undersluice /////////  river bed
   (sill 1.0-1.5 m above bed)   flushing gate

Importance of the intake

  • It is the link between the river and the waterway: the whole plant depends on it for the design discharge.
  • It controls the quality of water entering the plant: sediment, gravel and trash that pass the intake reach the settling basin, tunnel and turbines and cause abrasion and blockage.
  • It decides the head loss and so the energy generated; a poor intake gives vortices, air entry and heavy losses.
  • It provides flow control and safety: gates close during floods and for maintenance.
  • A wrongly placed intake can silt up, so its location and design decide the life and reliability of the headworks.

Deciding the location of an intake

  1. On the outer bank of a bend (about one-third to one-half way along the bend, downstream of the bend apex), where the helical flow carries bed load away from the opening; on a straight reach put it on the stable bank.
  2. In a stable reach with a good foundation, free of landslides, bank erosion and large boulder deposits.
  3. At a point that gives sufficient head and an easy alignment of the canal to the settling basin.
  4. Upstream of the weir and next to the undersluice so that the flushing current keeps the intake clear.
  5. Away from the confluence of tributaries, with good access and space for the gravel trap and settling basin.
  6. Where the river is narrow, to reduce the length and cost of the weir, and the flood level is limited.
  • 2082 Bhadra · 6 marks

Explain the usage of side intake, drop intake and frontal intake with sketches.

Answer

1. Side intake

The opening is made in the river bank, at an angle (normally 90-110°) to the flow, beside the weir. It has a sill, a trash rack and a gate.

 river ==========================>
        weir crest  ||||||||||||||
 bank   +----------------------+
   rack |  intake    gate  -----+--> canal
  • Used where the river carries bed load and boulders: the sill is raised and the undersluice keeps the intake clear. It is the most common in Nepal's RoR plants (steep gravel-boulder rivers).
  • The flow must turn 90°, so some sediment enters; a gravel trap is therefore needed.

2. Drop (bottom / Tyrolean) intake

A trench with inclined bars (rack) is built in the river bed across the flow; the water drops through the bars into a chamber and flows into a pipe or canal.

 flow ====>   inclined rack
        ______\\\\\\\\\\______
              |  chamber  |---> conduit
  • Used in steep mountain streams with small flow and coarse bed load, where the boulders pass over the rack.
  • Needs a large head of fall and takes much fine sediment; it is liable to clogging by leaves and gravel, so it needs regular cleaning.
  • Not suited to a large discharge.

3. Frontal intake

The opening is placed in line with the flow (in the weir or the dam face).

 river ===> |intake| ----> conduit
  • Entry losses are small and the structure is simple, but it takes in all the bed load; it is used only where the river is clean (e.g. a reservoir or a clean channel) or with a good sediment excluder in front.
  • 2072 Kartik · 2+3 marks

What are the requirements of a good intake? Explain different types of intake used in hydropower projects in Nepal with neat sketches.

Answer

Requirements of a good intake

  • Pass the design discharge in all river conditions, with the opening always submerged and no vortex or air entry.
  • Keep out bed load, sediment and floating trash (high sill, trash rack and boom).
  • Low head loss through a smooth, bell-mouthed entry and a short transition.
  • Structurally stable in floods; strong foundation; safe against scour and uplift.
  • Gates for regulation and shut-off, easy to operate; flushing arrangement in front of the intake.
  • Easy access for maintenance and for removal of trash and sediment.
  • Economical, with minimal impact on the environment and fish.

Types of intakes used in Nepal

  1. Side intake (most common): the opening is in the river bank next to the weir; the undersluice flushes the front.
  2. Bottom (Tyrolean) intake: a rack across the stream bed, used in steep streams, e.g. micro and small hydropower projects.
  3. Frontal intake (in the dam or weir face): used rarely.
  4. Reservoir/tunnel intake (submerged): a pressurised tower or inclined rack on a storage project.
 Side intake (plan)        Bottom intake (section)
 ===> weir  |||||||        flow ==> \\\\\\\\ rack
   rack |  gate -->               |____chamber____|-->
  • 2076 Chaitra · 2+6 marks

What are the main parts of non-pressurized and pressurized ROR intake? Present the general arrangement of such intakes in neat proportionate sketches.

Answer

Main parts of a non-pressurized RoR intake

  1. Approach channel / river training with guide wall.
  2. Intake sill (about 1.0-1.5 m above the undersluice or river bed) to stop bed load.
  3. Trash rack (inclined at 70-80°) with a trash boom in front.
  4. Gate (regulating gate) with a stop-log slot and hoist deck.
  5. Transition / bell-mouth to the gravel trap and the approach canal / settling basin.
  6. Flushing (undersluice) gate and flood wall.
NON-PRESSURIZED INTAKE (section)
 pond ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
      boom  | hoist deck
   --o--    |  |gate
 trash  |##\ |  |
 rack   |##  \|  |_______ free flow --> canal
 sill   |_______|
 ///////////////////////////// river bed

Main parts of a pressurized intake

  1. Approach and trash rack (inclined or vertical, large area, with rake).
  2. Bell-mouthed entrance (to reduce entry loss).
  3. Minimum submergence below the lowest operating level, with an anti-vortex device.
  4. Emergency gate and service gate in a gate shaft, with an air vent behind the gate.
  5. Transition from rectangular to the circular pressure tunnel/penstock.
PRESSURIZED INTAKE (section)
 min WL ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
        |  air vent
 rack   |##  |gate|
 S      |##  |    |
 _______|bell-|____> pressure tunnel (full)
        mouth

Proportions: rack velocity 0.8-1.0 m/s; the bell-mouth length is about 1.5-2 times the conduit height; the submergence is chosen by the vortex criterion S≥C VDS\ge C\,V\sqrt D.

  • 2073 Shrawan · 3+2 marks

Draw a neat sketch of a side intake with all components. How do you calculate the hydraulic loss at the trash rack?

Answer

Sketch of a side intake

PLAN
 river ==========================>
   weir |||||||  undersluice
   bank +---------------------+
        |trash rack  | gate   |--> gravel trap --> canal
        +---------------------+

SECTION
  pond ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
   boom o  |  rack (75°)  | gate | hoist deck
        ###|##\           |      |
        ###|###\__________|______|======> canal
   sill (1.0-1.5 m above undersluice)
 /////////////////////////////////////////// bed

Components: trash boom, trash rack with rake, intake sill, gate with stop-log slot, hoist deck, flushing undersluice and the transition to the canal.

Head loss at the trash rack (Kirschmer's formula)

ht=β(sb)4/3V22gsin⁡θh_t=\beta\left(\frac{s}{b}\right)^{4/3}\frac{V^2}{2g}\sin\theta

where hth_t is the head loss (m), β\beta the bar shape factor (2.42 for rectangular, 1.83 for rectangular bars with round upstream edges, 1.79 for circular bars, 0.76 for streamlined bars), ss the bar thickness, bb the clear spacing between bars, VV the approach velocity (m/s) and θ\theta the angle of the rack from the horizontal.

For a clogged rack the loss is increased by taking an additional allowance; a clogging factor of 25-50% is used, and the total head loss for the design of the intake should include it.

Example: bars 10 mm thick at 100 mm clear spacing, circular (β=1.79\beta=1.79), V=0.8V=0.8 m/s, θ=75∘\theta=75^\circ:

ht=1.79 (0.1)4/30.8219.62sin⁡75∘=1.79×0.0464×0.0326×0.966=0.0026 mh_t=1.79\,(0.1)^{4/3}\frac{0.8^2}{19.62}\sin75^\circ=1.79\times0.0464\times0.0326\times0.966=0.0026\ \text{m}

which is very small, so the rack loss is negligible when clean.

  • 2080 Baishakh · 6 marks

How do you evaluate losses in intakes?

Answer

The head loss in an intake is the sum of the following parts. Each is computed as a coefficient times a velocity head, except friction.

  1. Trash rack loss (Kirschmer):
ht=β(sb)4/3Va22gsin⁡θh_t=\beta\left(\frac{s}{b}\right)^{4/3}\frac{V_a^2}{2g}\sin\theta

with β\beta = bar shape factor (2.42 rectangular, 1.79 circular), ss = bar thickness, bb = clear spacing, VaV_a = approach velocity and θ\theta = rack inclination. For a partly clogged rack, increase the loss using the blocked area (net velocity).

  1. Entrance loss: he=keV22gh_e=k_e\dfrac{V^2}{2g}, where ke=0.5k_e=0.5 for a sharp-edged entrance, 0.2 for a rounded, and 0.05-0.1 for a well-shaped bell-mouth.

  2. Gate slot loss: hg=kgV22gh_g=k_g\dfrac{V^2}{2g}, with kg≈0.1k_g\approx0.1 (nil for a fully open gate with flush slot).

  3. Transition loss (contraction or expansion): htr=k(V2−V1)22gh_{tr}=k\dfrac{(V_2-V_1)^2}{2g}, with k≈0.1k\approx0.1 for a gradual contraction and 0.2-0.3 for an expansion.

  4. Bend loss: hb=kbV22gh_b=k_b\dfrac{V^2}{2g}, where kb≈0.1−0.25k_b\approx0.1-0.25 depends on the radius and angle.

  5. Friction loss in the intake conduit (Manning/Darcy):

hf=n2V2LR4/3orhf=fLDV22gh_f=\frac{n^2V^2L}{R^{4/3}}\quad\text{or}\quad h_f=f\frac{L}{D}\frac{V^2}{2g}

Total loss

hL=ht+he+hg+htr+hb+hfh_L=h_t+h_e+h_g+h_{tr}+h_b+h_f

The loss is minimised by a low velocity at the rack (about 0.8-1.0 m/s), a bell-mouthed entrance, smooth gradual transitions and few gate slots. For a typical RoR intake the total is of the order of 0.1-0.3 m, and it is subtracted from the net head of the plant.

  • 2072 Chaitra · 3+1 marks

Draw a neat sketch of a hydropower intake, showing major components. How do you minimize head loss in the intake?

Answer

Sketch of a hydropower intake (non-pressurized side intake of a RoR plant)

PLAN
 river ==========================>
   weir |||||||| undersluice
   bank +----------------------+
        | rack    gate  bell   |--> gravel trap --> canal
        +----------------------+

SECTION
 pond ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
  boom o  | trash rack | gate | hoist deck
          |###\        |      |
          |####\_______|______|=====> conduit
   sill (1.0-1.5 m above bed)   transition
 ///////////////////////////////////////// bed

Major components: trash boom, trash rack (inclined), intake sill, regulating gate with stop-log slot, hoist deck, bell-mouthed transition, flushing undersluice and the conduit to the gravel trap or settling basin.

Minimising head loss in the intake

Head loss reduces the net head and so the energy produced. It is reduced by:

  • Low velocity at the trash rack (0.6-1.0 m/s) by providing a large rack area; the loss varies with V2V^2.
  • Streamlined bars (rounded or tapered upstream edges, β\beta of 0.76-1.8 instead of 2.42), larger spacing, and regular raking to avoid clogging.
  • Bell-mouthed, rounded entrance instead of a sharp-edged entry (loss coefficient 0.05-0.1 instead of 0.5).
  • Gradual transitions (contraction or expansion not steeper than about 1:5) and smooth curved wing walls.
  • Few gate slots and piers, and a fully open gate in operation.
  • Smooth lining, short conduit and large bend radius; avoiding sharp bends at the entry.
  • 2079 Bhadra · 2+4 marks

Why is a vortex formed in an intake? Discuss the hydraulic conditions for no vortex formation.

Answer

Why a vortex forms

A vortex forms when water approaches a submerged intake with angular momentum (circulation) and insufficient submergence. As the flow converges to the opening its velocity rises and the surface is drawn down by the low pressure at the centre, so a rotating core develops and may draw air into the intake. Typical causes:

  • small submergence of the intake above its crown;
  • asymmetric approach flow, flow past piers, abutments or the bank, giving circulation;
  • high intake velocity and high Froude number;
  • sharp edges, no guide walls, and sudden changes in direction.

Vortices cause air entrainment (reduced capacity and turbine efficiency), vibration, surging, cavitation, and carry floating trash into the intake.

Conditions for no vortex formation

  1. Adequate submergence (Gordon's formula):
S=C VDS=C\,V\sqrt{D}

where SS is the submergence (water surface to the crown of the intake, m), VV the velocity in the intake (m/s), DD the height or diameter of the intake (m), and C=0.7245C=0.7245 for symmetrical approach flow and 0.54340.5434 for an asymmetrical approach. An alternative criterion (Knauss) is S/D≥1+2.3 FrS/D\ge1+2.3\,Fr with Fr=V/gDFr=V/\sqrt{gD}. 2. Low intake velocity (less than about 1 m/s at the rack, and the Froude number kept low). 3. Symmetrical, smooth approach flow, with guide walls to remove circulation; avoid sharp bends and eddies. 4. Anti-vortex devices: floating rafts or beams, vertical splitter walls or baffles above the intake, and a trash rack that breaks rotation. 5. Bell-mouth entry of a good shape and a sufficient depth of the intake sill above the bed.

  • 2082 Baishakh · 7 marks

Design an orifice type intake for a ROR plant having design discharge of 5 m³/s. The difference of elevations between the weir crest level and the river bed level is 2.5 m. The difference of elevations between the weir crest level and the designed canal water surface level is 0.3 m. The intake velocity is limited to 0.8 m/s. Take coefficient of discharge as 0.6, coefficient of contraction as 0.03, and coefficient of trash rack bar as 1.83.

Answer

Given: Q=5Q=5 m³/s; weir crest is 2.5 m above the river bed; canal water level is 0.3 m below the crest; intake velocity ≤0.8\le0.8 m/s; Cd=0.6C_d=0.6; bar-contraction coefficient 0.03; trash-rack bar shape factor β=1.83\beta=1.83.

Step 1: Net opening area from the velocity limit

Anet=QV=50.8=6.25 m2A_{net}=\frac{Q}{V}=\frac{5}{0.8}=6.25\ \text{m}^2

Step 2: Gross area allowing for the bars

The bars reduce the opening by the contraction coefficient 0.03:

Agross=Anet1−0.03=6.250.97=6.44 m2A_{gross}=\frac{A_{net}}{1-0.03}=\frac{6.25}{0.97}=6.44\ \text{m}^2

Step 3: Dimensions of the opening

Sill level 1.0 m above the river bed (to keep bed load out). Take the height of the orifice h=1.2h=1.2 m so that its top is at 2.2 m above the bed, i.e. at the canal water level (0.3 m below the crest), so the opening stays submerged.

b=Agrossh=6.441.2=5.37 m ⇒ adopt 5.4 m (2 bays of 2.7 m)b=\frac{A_{gross}}{h}=\frac{6.44}{1.2}=5.37\ \text{m}\ \Rightarrow\ \text{adopt }5.4\ \text{m (2 bays of 2.7 m)}

Adopted opening area A=1.2×5.4=6.48A=1.2\times5.4=6.48 m².

Step 4: Head required across the orifice (check)

Q=CdA2g Δh ⇒ Δh=12g(QCdA)2=119.62(50.6×6.48)2=0.084 mQ=C_dA\sqrt{2g\,\Delta h}\ \Rightarrow\ \Delta h=\frac{1}{2g}\left(\frac{Q}{C_dA}\right)^2=\frac{1}{19.62}\left(\frac{5}{0.6\times6.48}\right)^2=0.084\ \text{m}

Available head difference =0.3=0.3 m >0.084>0.084 m, so the opening can pass the design flow; the extra head is absorbed by throttling the gate.

For comparison, the area that would pass 5 m³/s under the full 0.3 m head is A=50.62g(0.3)=3.43A=\dfrac{5}{0.6\sqrt{2g(0.3)}}=3.43 m², so the velocity limit (6.25 m²) controls the size.

Step 5: Trash rack loss (Kirschmer)

Assume bars 10 mm thick at 50 mm clear spacing, inclined at 75∘75^\circ:

ht=β(sb)4/3V22gsin⁡θ=1.83(1050)4/30.8219.62sin⁡75∘=0.0067 mh_t=\beta\left(\frac{s}{b}\right)^{4/3}\frac{V^2}{2g}\sin\theta=1.83\left(\frac{10}{50}\right)^{4/3}\frac{0.8^2}{19.62}\sin75^\circ=0.0067\ \text{m}
 SECTION                         PLAN
 crest 2.5 ~~~~~~~~~~~~          river ==>
        |   |gate|  2.2         |rack|gate|--> canal
  rack  |## |    |~~~~ canal    | 5.4 m opening |
 sill   |___|____|              2 bays of 2.7 m
 1.0 m above bed

Answer: orifice opening 5.4 m×1.25.4\ \text{m}\times1.2 m with sill 1.0 m above the bed (2 bays of 2.7 m); required head 0.0840.084 m < 0.3 m available; rack loss ≈0.0067\approx0.0067 m.

  • 2078 Bhadra · 6 marks

Design and draw a section of a side intake for a project in which the river bed level is 3315.0 masl. Weir crest level is fixed at 3317.5 masl. The highest flood level in 100 years return period is 3319.55 masl. The canal water level is fixed at 3317.3 masl. The turbine discharge of a period is 1.45 m³/s. Assume other suitable data. Take cylindrical trashrack bar with 10 mm thickness and 100 mm spacing.

Answer

Given: river bed RL 3315.00 m; weir crest RL 3317.50 m; 100-year flood level RL 3319.55 m; canal water level RL 3317.30 m; Q=1.45Q=1.45 m³/s; circular bars 10 mm thick at 100 mm clear spacing. Assumed: rack velocity 0.8 m/s, rack inclined 75∘75^\circ, Cd=0.6C_d=0.6 for the gate orifice.

Step 1: Level of the sill and opening

  • Sill level: 1.0 m above the river bed, i.e. RL 3316.00 m, to keep bed load out.
  • Opening height h=1.3h=1.3 m, so the top of the opening is RL 3317.30 m, which is the canal water level and 0.2 m below the weir crest, so the opening stays submerged at low flow.

Step 2: Rack area and width

Anet=QV=1.450.8=1.812 m2A_{net}=\frac{Q}{V}=\frac{1.45}{0.8}=1.812\ \text{m}^2 Agross=Anet×s+bb=1.812×110100=1.994 m2A_{gross}=A_{net}\times\frac{s+b}{b}=1.812\times\frac{110}{100}=1.994\ \text{m}^2 width =Agrossh=1.9941.3=1.53 m ⇒ adopt 1.6 m\text{width }=\frac{A_{gross}}{h}=\frac{1.994}{1.3}=1.53\ \text{m}\ \Rightarrow\ \text{adopt }1.6\ \text{m}

Adopted gross opening 1.6×1.3=2.081.6\times1.3=2.08 m²; net area =2.08×100110=1.891=2.08\times\frac{100}{110}=1.891 m²; actual velocity V=1.451.891=0.767V=\dfrac{1.45}{1.891}=0.767 m/s (< 1 m/s, so acceptable).

Step 3: Orifice check at normal pond level

Head difference between pond (crest RL 3317.50) and canal (RL 3317.30) =0.2=0.2 m.

Qcap=CdA2gΔh=0.6×2.08×19.62×0.2=2.47 m3/s>1.45Q_{cap}=C_dA\sqrt{2g\Delta h}=0.6\times2.08\times\sqrt{19.62\times0.2}=2.47\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}>1.45

Required head Δh=12g(1.450.6×2.08)2=0.069\Delta h=\dfrac{1}{2g}\left(\dfrac{1.45}{0.6\times2.08}\right)^2=0.069 m. The gate is throttled to keep the canal level at RL 3317.30 m.

Step 4: Trash rack loss (Kirschmer)

ht=β(sb)4/3V22gsin⁡θ=1.79 (0.1)4/30.767219.62sin⁡75∘=0.0024 mh_t=\beta\left(\frac{s}{b}\right)^{4/3}\frac{V^2}{2g}\sin\theta=1.79\,(0.1)^{4/3}\frac{0.767^2}{19.62}\sin75^\circ=0.0024\ \text{m}

which is negligible.

Step 5: Flood condition and levels

At the 100-year flood RL 3319.55 m the head on the opening centre (RL 3316.65 m) is 2.902.90 m. Without control the intake would pass 0.6×2.082g×2.90=9.40.6\times2.08\sqrt{2g\times2.90}=9.4 m³/s, so the gate is closed or throttled; for 1.45 m³/s the opening area is only 1.450.62g×2.90=0.32\dfrac{1.45}{0.6\sqrt{2g\times2.90}}=0.32 m² (gate opening of about 0.20 m). Top of the intake wall and hoist deck: flood level + 0.6 m free board == RL 3320.15 m.

SECTION (levels in m)
 3320.15 ____ deck
 3319.55 ~~~~~ HFL
 3317.50 ~~~~~~~~~~ weir crest (pond level)
          | rack  |gate|
 3317.30  |###\   |    |~~ canal WL 3317.30
          |###     |    |
 3316.00  |_____sill____|   (1.0 m above bed)
 3315.00 /////////////// river bed

Answer: sill RL 3316.00 m; opening 1.6 m wide x 1.3 m high (top RL 3317.30 m); rack velocity 0.767 m/s; rack loss 0.0024 m; deck RL 3320.15 m.

  • 2075 Chaitra · 5 marks

Determine the necessary length of a rack of a bottom intake with the intercepted flow of 8 m³/s and width of the rack of 10 m. Inclination of the rack is 30°. Thickness, spacing and contraction factor of the bars are 10 mm, 15 mm and 0.82 respectively.

Answer

Given: intercepted flow Q=8Q=8 m³/s; rack width B=10B=10 m; rack inclination α=30∘\alpha=30^\circ; bar thickness s=10s=10 mm; clear spacing b=15b=15 mm; contraction factor c=0.82c=0.82.

Assumptions: the water arrives at the rack at critical depth (over the weir crest), and the specific energy E=1.5 hcE=1.5\,h_c stays nearly constant along the short rack (Noseda/Mostkow approximation).

Step 1: Unit discharge and energy

q=QB=810=0.8 m2/s,hc=(q2g)1/3=0.403 m,E=1.5hc=0.604 mq=\frac{Q}{B}=\frac{8}{10}=0.8\ \text{m}^2/\text{s},\qquad h_c=\left(\frac{q^2}{g}\right)^{1/3}=0.403\ \text{m},\qquad E=1.5h_c=0.604\ \text{m}

Step 2: Opening ratio

ε=bb+s=1515+10=0.60\varepsilon=\frac{b}{b+s}=\frac{15}{15+10}=0.60

Step 3: Discharge passing through the rack per unit plan area

qb=c εcos⁡α2gE=0.82×0.60×cos⁡30∘×2×9.81×0.604=1.467 m3/s per m2 (=m/s)q_b=c\,\varepsilon\cos\alpha\sqrt{2gE}=0.82\times0.60\times\cos30^\circ\times\sqrt{2\times9.81\times0.604}=1.467\ \text{m}^3/\text{s per m}^2\ (=\text{m/s})

Step 4: Length of the rack

All the unit flow qq must pass through the rack:

L=qqb=0.81.467=0.55 mL=\frac{q}{q_b}=\frac{0.8}{1.467}=0.55\ \text{m}

Allow 25% extra for partial clogging by gravel and leaves: L=1.25×0.55=0.68L=1.25\times0.55=0.68 m. Adopt about 0.7 m.

Answer: required rack length ≈0.55\approx0.55 m; adopt 0.70.7 m (rack 10 m wide, inclined at 30∘30^\circ).

  • 2069 Chaitra · 6 marks

How is the control of bed load and floating debris in a ROR intake done? Explain with appropriate plan and sectional drawings of the system.

Answer

In a RoR plant on a steep Himalayan river, bed load (gravel, boulders) and floating debris (logs, leaves, trash) must be kept out of the intake. This is done by the arrangement shown below.

PLAN
 river ====================================>
        scour sluice (undersluice)  ||||||| weir
   +---+====================+
   |  flood   divide wall    |
   |  wall   --> gravel trap |--> canal to
   | rack|gate               |    settling basin
   +---------------------------+
   trash boom o-o-o-o (angled)

SECTION (through intake)
 pond ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
   boom o   | rack |gate|
            |###\  |    |==> canal
   sill 1.0-1.5 m above undersluice floor
 //// undersluice floor (low) ////  --> flushing

Control of bed load

  1. High intake sill: the intake floor is placed 1.0-1.5 m (or more) above the undersluice crest or river bed, so the bed load rolls past.
  2. Undersluice (scouring sluice) next to the intake, with gates, creates a flushing channel in front of it; it is opened during floods to scour deposits, and the divide wall separates the intake from the sluice.
  3. Intake location on the outer bank of the bend, where the secondary flow moves bed load to the inner bank.
  4. Curtain (skimming) wall or bed-load excluder: only the upper clear water is drawn.
  5. Gravel trap after the intake with flushing arrangement, and a settling basin for sand.
  6. Guide bunds and training walls keep a stable flow line near the intake.

Control of floating debris

  1. Trash boom (floating or fixed), set at an angle to the flow, deflects logs and trash towards the weir spill or sluice.
  2. Trash rack (clear spacing about 50-100 mm) with an automatic or manual rake, inclined at about 75°.
  3. Skimming walls and a surface spillway pass the floating material over the weir.
  4. Low velocity at the rack (0.6-1.0 m/s) so the debris does not hold on the bars.
  5. Periodic inspection and cleaning in the monsoon.
  • 2072 Kartik · 5+2 marks

Find the dimensions of a settling basin for a high head project of a Himalayan river which utilizes a discharge of 60 m³/s and a gross head of 100 m. The sediment size to be removed is up to 0.15 mm. Consider the turbulence effect also. Draw the plan and section.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=60.0Q=60.0 m³/s and gross head 100 m; particles of size d≥0.15d\ge 0.15 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=1.50w=1.50 cm/s =0.0150=0.0150 m/s (taken for 0.15 mm quartz sand). Turbulence is considered.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.15=17.04 cm/s=0.1704 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.15}=17.04\ \text{cm/s}=0.1704\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=6.0H=6.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=60.00.1704×6.0=58.68 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{60.0}{0.1704\times6.0}=58.68\ \text{m}

Provide n=3n=3 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=19.56b=B/n=19.56 m each, adopt 20.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1704×6.00.0150=68.2 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1704\times6.0}{0.0150}=68.2\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.17046.0=0.0092 m/sw′=0.0150−0.0092=0.0058 m/sL=vHw′=0.1704×6.00.0058=175.8 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1704}{\sqrt{6.0}}=0.0092\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0150-0.0092=0.0058\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1704\times6.0}{0.0058}=175.8\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.170 m/s
Settling depth HH6.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers3
Width of each chamber20.0 m
Length of settling zone180 m
Length/width ratio9.0
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈64800\approx 64800 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 3 chambers, each about 20.0 m wide x 180 m long x 6.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.170v=0.170 m/s.

  • 2075 Chaitra · 8 marks

Find the dimensions of the settling basin for a high head project of a Himalayan river which carries a discharge of 30 m³/s and a gross head of 100 m. The sediment size to be removed is up to 0.20 mm and fall velocity ω = 2 cm/sec. If the turbulence is considered, what will be the dimension of the basin? Check the length of the settling basin using Velikanov's method given correction factor λ = 1.5.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=30.0Q=30.0 m³/s and gross head 100 m; particles of size d≥0.20d\ge 0.20 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=2.00w=2.00 cm/s =0.0200=0.0200 m/s (given). The result is first found without turbulence, then with turbulence, and checked with Velikanov's method (λ=1.5\lambda=1.5).

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.20=19.68 cm/s=0.1968 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.20}=19.68\ \text{cm/s}=0.1968\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=5.0H=5.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=30.00.1968×5.0=30.49 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{30.0}{0.1968\times5.0}=30.49\ \text{m}

Provide n=2n=2 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=15.25b=B/n=15.25 m each, adopt 15.5 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1968×5.00.0200=49.2 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1968\times5.0}{0.0200}=49.2\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.19685.0=0.0116 m/sw′=0.0200−0.0116=0.0084 m/sL=vHw′=0.1968×5.00.0084=117.4 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1968}{\sqrt{5.0}}=0.0116\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0200-0.0116=0.0084\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1968\times5.0}{0.0084}=117.4\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Step 5: Check by Velikanov's method

LV=λ2v2(H−0.2)27.51 w2=1.52×0.19682×(5.0−0.2)27.51×0.02002=120.2 mL_V=\frac{\lambda^2v^2(\sqrt H-0.2)^2}{7.51\,w^2}=\frac{1.5^2\times0.1968^2\times(\sqrt{5.0}-0.2)^2}{7.51\times0.0200^2}=120.2\ \text{m}

The Velikanov length (120.2 m) is 2% greater than the turbulence length (117.4 m). The larger of the two is adopted and rounded up, giving 125 m.

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.197 m/s
Settling depth HH5.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers2
Width of each chamber15.5 m
Length of settling zone125 m
Length/width ratio8.1
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈19375\approx 19375 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 2 chambers, each about 15.5 m wide x 125 m long x 5.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.197v=0.197 m/s.

  • 2070 Chaitra · 6+3 marks

Find out the dimension of a continuous flushing settling basin for a high head project in a Himalayan river which utilizes a discharge of 60 m³/s and head of 300 m; the sediment particles larger than 0.15 mm have to be trapped with efficiency 95% in the basin. Consider the effect of turbulence and check the length of the basin using Velikanov's relation for the density of the silty water of 1.105 ton/m³. Draw plan and section of the basin showing major components.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=60.0Q=60.0 m³/s and gross head 300 m; particles of size d≥0.15d\ge 0.15 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=1.50w=1.50 cm/s =0.0150=0.0150 m/s (taken for 0.15 mm sand, as in similar designs). The basin has continuous flushing, so 10% extra flow (6 m³/s) is added. The trap efficiency required is 95% for particles larger than 0.15 mm, and the turbulence effect is included. Velikanov's relation is checked with λ=1.5\lambda=1.5 and silty water of density 1.105 t/m³.

Flushing water of 10% is added for continuous flushing, so the design flow of the basin is Q′=60.0+6.0=66.0Q'=60.0+6.0=66.0 m³/s.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.15=17.04 cm/s=0.1704 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.15}=17.04\ \text{cm/s}=0.1704\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=6.0H=6.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=66.00.1704×6.0=64.55 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{66.0}{0.1704\times6.0}=64.55\ \text{m}

Provide n=3n=3 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=21.52b=B/n=21.52 m each, adopt 22.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1704×6.00.0150=68.2 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1704\times6.0}{0.0150}=68.2\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.17046.0=0.0092 m/sw′=0.0150−0.0092=0.0058 m/sL=vHw′=0.1704×6.00.0058=175.8 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1704}{\sqrt{6.0}}=0.0092\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0150-0.0092=0.0058\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1704\times6.0}{0.0058}=175.8\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Step 5: Check by Velikanov's method

The silty water has density 1.105 t/m³ (sediment 2.65 t/m³), which reduces the effective fall velocity by the buoyancy ratio 2.65−1.1052.65−1=0.936\frac{2.65-1.105}{2.65-1}=0.936, so ws=1.405w_s=1.405 cm/s.

LV=λ2v2(H−0.2)27.51 ws2=1.52×0.17042×(6.0−0.2)27.51×0.014052=223.2 mL_V=\frac{\lambda^2v^2(\sqrt H-0.2)^2}{7.51\,w_s^2}=\frac{1.5^2\times0.1704^2\times(\sqrt{6.0}-0.2)^2}{7.51\times0.01405^2}=223.2\ \text{m}

The Velikanov length (223.2 m) is 27% greater than the turbulence length (175.8 m). The larger of the two is adopted and rounded up, giving 225 m.

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.170 m/s
Settling depth HH6.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers3
Width of each chamber22.0 m
Length of settling zone225 m
Length/width ratio10.2
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈89100\approx 89100 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

The adopted length is greater than the Velikanov length, so more than 95% of the particles coarser than 0.15 mm are expected to be trapped. Continuous flushing is done through a longitudinal slot (or hoppers) below each chamber, carrying 6 m³/s of flushing water back to the river.

Answer: 3 chambers, each about 22.0 m wide x 225 m long x 6.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.170v=0.170 m/s.

  • 2082 Bhadra · 8 marks

Design a single chamber settling basin using the following data: design discharge = 15 m³/sec; particle size to settle ≥ 0.2 mm; particle fall velocity = 0.02 m/sec; factor of safety for basin area = 1.5; length to breadth ratio = 8; sediment concentration = 1 kg/m³; density of sediment particles = 2,500 kg/m³; settling time of sediment particles = 8 hours; sediment packing factor = 0.5; additional discharge for flushing = 10%.

Answer

Given: Q=15Q=15 m³/s, particles ≥0.2\ge0.2 mm, w=0.02w=0.02 m/s, factor of safety for area =1.5=1.5, L/B=8L/B=8, sediment concentration C=1C=1 kg/m³, particle density 2500 kg/m³, flushing interval 8 h, packing factor 0.5, additional flushing discharge 10%.

Step 1: Design flow

Q′=1.10×15=16.5 m3/sQ'=1.10\times15=16.5\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}

Step 2: Surface area of the basin

For a particle to settle, the surface area must satisfy A≥Q/wA\ge Q/w. With the factor of safety:

A=FS×Q′w=1.5×16.50.02=1237.5 m2A=\frac{FS\times Q'}{w}=\frac{1.5\times16.5}{0.02}=1237.5\ \text{m}^2

Step 3: Width and length (L/B=8L/B=8)

B=A8=1237.58=12.44 m,L=8B=99.5 mB=\sqrt{\frac{A}{8}}=\sqrt{\frac{1237.5}{8}}=12.44\ \text{m},\qquad L=8B=99.5\ \text{m}

Adopt B=13B=13 m and L=104L=104 m (A=1352A=1352 m²).

Step 4: Depth of flow

Limit the horizontal velocity to about 0.3 m/s. Take the flow depth H=4.5H=4.5 m:

v=Q′BH=16.513×4.5=0.282 m/s<0.3 m/s(OK)v=\frac{Q'}{BH}=\frac{16.5}{13\times4.5}=0.282\ \text{m/s}<0.3\ \text{m/s}\quad\text{(OK)}

Step 5: Sediment storage (flushing every 8 h)

Mass of sediment=C Q′ t=1×16.5×(8×3600)=475200 kg\text{Mass of sediment}=C\,Q'\,t=1\times16.5\times(8\times3600)=475200\ \text{kg} Volume of deposit=massρs×p=4752002500×0.5=380.2 m3\text{Volume of deposit}=\frac{\text{mass}}{\rho_s\times p}=\frac{475200}{2500\times0.5}=380.2\ \text{m}^3 Depth of deposit=380.21352=0.28 m ⇒ provide 0.5 m storage\text{Depth of deposit}=\frac{380.2}{1352}=0.28\ \text{m}\ \Rightarrow\ \text{provide }0.5\ \text{m storage}

(All the sediment entering is assumed to be trapped, which is conservative.)

Step 6: Overall dimensions

ItemValue
Length of settling zone104 m
Width13 m
Flow depth4.5 m
Sediment storage0.5 m (hopper with 1:30 slope to the flushing channel)
Free board0.5 m
Total depth at the upstream endabout 5.5 m
PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river

Answer: single chamber of about 13 m x 104 m, flow depth 4.5 m (v=0.282v=0.282 m/s) with 0.5 m sediment storage, to be flushed every 8 hours (deposit 380.2 m³ per cycle).

  • 2081 Bhadra · 7 marks

Design a desander using the following data: discharge = 16 m³/s, particle size to be settled ≥ 0.2 mm, particle fall velocity = 0.022 m/s, horizontal flow velocity = 0.2 m/s. Consider two basins with a factor of safety for basin area of 1.5. Use length-to-breadth ratio of 6. Assume a sediment concentration of 1 kg/m³, a sediment particle density of 2650 kg/m³, a settling time of 1 day, a sediment packing factor of 0.5, and an additional 10% discharge for flushing.

Answer

Given: Q=16Q=16 m³/s, particle ≥0.2\ge0.2 mm with w=0.022w=0.022 m/s, horizontal velocity v=0.2v=0.2 m/s, two basins, factor of safety 1.5, L/B=6L/B=6, C=1C=1 kg/m³, ρs=2650\rho_s=2650 kg/m³, settling (flushing) time 1 day, packing factor 0.5, extra discharge for flushing 10%.

Step 1: Design flow

Q′=1.10×16=17.6 m3/sQ'=1.10\times16=17.6\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}

Step 2: Surface area

Atotal=FS Q′w=1.5×17.60.022=1200.0 m2⇒Abasin=1200.02=600.0 m2A_{total}=\frac{FS\,Q'}{w}=\frac{1.5\times17.6}{0.022}=1200.0\ \text{m}^2\quad\Rightarrow\quad A_{basin}=\frac{1200.0}{2}=600.0\ \text{m}^2

Step 3: Plan size of one basin

B=Abasin6=600.06=10.00 m,L=6B=60.0 mB=\sqrt{\frac{A_{basin}}{6}}=\sqrt{\frac{600.0}{6}}=10.00\ \text{m},\qquad L=6B=60.0\ \text{m}

Adopt B=10B=10 m, L=60L=60 m.

Step 4: Depth of flow

Flow in one basin =Q′/2=8.8=Q'/2=8.8 m³/s; with v=0.2v=0.2 m/s:

H=Q′/2B v=8.810×0.2=4.40 m ⇒ adopt 4.5 mH=\frac{Q'/2}{B\,v}=\frac{8.8}{10\times0.2}=4.40\ \text{m}\ \Rightarrow\ \text{adopt }4.5\ \text{m}

Step 5: Sediment storage (1 day)

Mass=C Q′ t=1×17.6×86400=1520640 kgVolume=15206402650×0.5=1148 m3 (both basins)Depth per basin=1148/2600.0=0.96 m\begin{aligned} \text{Mass}&=C\,Q'\,t=1\times17.6\times86400=1520640\ \text{kg}\\ \text{Volume}&=\frac{1520640}{2650\times0.5}=1148\ \text{m}^3\ \text{(both basins)}\\ \text{Depth per basin}&=\frac{1148/2}{600.0}=0.96\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Provide about 1.0 m of sediment storage in the hopper below the flow depth (or flush more often, as in practice).

ItemValue
Number of basins2
Size of each basin10 m wide x 60 m long
Flow depth4.5 m
Sediment storage depthabout 1.0 m
Total depthabout 5.5 m + 0.5 m free board

Answer: 2 basins, each 10 m x 60 m in plan with a flow depth of 4.5 m and 1.0 m storage depth.

  • 2082 Baishakh · 5+2 marks

Determine the dimensions of a desilting basin for a high head hydropower plant with a discharge of 32 m³/s. The basin must trap sediment particles coarser than 0.15 mm. Take w = 0.025 m/s and λ = 1.5. Additionally, draw a plan and longitudinal section of the desilting basin, illustrating the major components and the flushing arrangement.

Answer

Given: Q=32Q=32 m³/s, particles coarser than 0.15 mm, w=0.025w=0.025 m/s, λ=1.5\lambda=1.5 (turbulence/safety coefficient). High head plant, so two chambers are provided, one flushed while the other works.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

v=440.15=17.04 cm/s=0.1704 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.15}=17.04\ \text{cm/s}=0.1704\ \text{m/s}

Step 2: Surface area with turbulence coefficient

A=λQw=1.5×320.025=1920 m2A=\frac{\lambda Q}{w}=\frac{1.5\times32}{0.025}=1920\ \text{m}^2

Step 3: Depth, width and length

Assume a flow depth H=5H=5 m:

B=QvH=320.1704×5=37.56 m (two chambers of 18.78 m),L=AB=192037.56=51.1 mB=\frac{Q}{vH}=\frac{32}{0.1704\times5}=37.56\ \text{m}\ (\text{two chambers of }18.78\ \text{m}),\qquad L=\frac{A}{B}=\frac{1920}{37.56}=51.1\ \text{m}

Check: L=λvHw=1.5×0.1704×50.025=51.1L=\dfrac{\lambda vH}{w}=\dfrac{1.5\times0.1704\times5}{0.025}=51.1 m. Adopt L=55L=55 m, chamber width 19.019.0 m, giving L/b=2.9L/b=2.9.

ItemValue
Number of chambers2
Width of each chamber19.0 m
Length55 m
Flow depth5 m (+ 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Velocity0.1704 m/s
PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: each chamber has a hopper floor sloping to a central flushing channel (slope 1:30) and a flushing gate at the downstream end; the inlet gate of the chamber is closed, the chamber is flushed, and the other chamber carries the flow meanwhile. Flushing water runs through the flushing tunnel to the river.

Answer: 2 chambers, each 19.0 m wide x 55 m long x 5 m deep (plus storage).

  • 2079 Bhadra · 8 marks

Design a continuous type settling basin with neat sketches for a hydropower plant using the following data: settling velocity = 5 cm/sec; turbine discharge = 10 m³/sec; particle size to be removed = 0.15 mm. Assume other necessary data if necessary.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=10.0Q=10.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.15d\ge 0.15 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=5.00w=5.00 cm/s =0.0500=0.0500 m/s (given). The basin is of the continuous flushing type, so a flushing discharge of 10% (1.0 m³/s) is added. Turbulence is included, and other data are assumed. (A fall velocity of 5 cm/s is high for 0.15 mm sand, so the length is short; the given value is used.)

Flushing water of 10% is added for continuous flushing, so the design flow of the basin is Q′=10.0+1.0=11.0Q'=10.0+1.0=11.0 m³/s.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.15=17.04 cm/s=0.1704 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.15}=17.04\ \text{cm/s}=0.1704\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=3.0H=3.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=11.00.1704×3.0=21.52 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{11.0}{0.1704\times3.0}=21.52\ \text{m}

Provide n=2n=2 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=10.76b=B/n=10.76 m each, adopt 11.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1704×3.00.0500=10.2 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1704\times3.0}{0.0500}=10.2\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.17043.0=0.0130 m/sw′=0.0500−0.0130=0.0370 m/sL=vHw′=0.1704×3.00.0370=13.8 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1704}{\sqrt{3.0}}=0.0130\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0500-0.0130=0.0370\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1704\times3.0}{0.0370}=13.8\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.170 m/s
Settling depth HH3.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers2
Width of each chamber11.0 m
Length of settling zone15 m
Length/width ratio1.4
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈990\approx 990 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 2 chambers, each about 11.0 m wide x 15 m long x 3.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.170v=0.170 m/s.

  • 2080 Bhadra · 7 marks

Design a settling basin for a design discharge of 6 cumec. The basin is designed to remove particle size of 0.25 mm. If the depth of the basin is 3 m and settling velocity 2.5 cm/sec, find the dimensions of the basin considering turbulence.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=6.0Q=6.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.25d\ge 0.25 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=2.50w=2.50 cm/s =0.0250=0.0250 m/s (given). Depth of the basin is 3 m and turbulence is considered.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.25=22.00 cm/s=0.2200 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.25}=22.00\ \text{cm/s}=0.2200\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=3.0H=3.0 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=6.00.2200×3.0=9.09 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{6.0}{0.2200\times3.0}=9.09\ \text{m}

Provide n=2n=2 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=4.55b=B/n=4.55 m each, adopt 5.0 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.2200×3.00.0250=26.4 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.2200\times3.0}{0.0250}=26.4\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.22003.0=0.0168 m/sw′=0.0250−0.0168=0.0082 m/sL=vHw′=0.2200×3.00.0082=80.2 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.2200}{\sqrt{3.0}}=0.0168\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0250-0.0168=0.0082\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.2200\times3.0}{0.0082}=80.2\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.220 m/s
Settling depth HH3.0 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers2
Width of each chamber5.0 m
Length of settling zone85 m
Length/width ratio17.0
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈2550\approx 2550 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Answer: 2 chambers, each about 5.0 m wide x 85 m long x 3.0 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.220v=0.220 m/s.

  • 2069 Chaitra · 8 marks

Compute the dimension of a periodic type settling basin considering and without considering the turbulence effect for a hydropower plant through settling theory. Take settling velocity = 6 cm/sec; discharge = 5 m³/sec; particle size to be removed = 0.2 mm; depth of basin = 2.4 m.

Answer

Given: design discharge Q=5.0Q=5.0 m³/s; particles of size d≥0.20d\ge 0.20 mm to be trapped, fall velocity w=6.00w=6.00 cm/s =0.0600=0.0600 m/s (given). Periodic (intermittent) flushing is used, so no extra flushing discharge is added; the basin is designed both without and with turbulence.

Step 1: Horizontal velocity (Camp)

For 0.1<d<10.1<d<1 mm, v=adv=a\sqrt d with a=44a=44 (v in cm/s, d in mm):

v=440.20=19.68 cm/s=0.1968 m/sv=44\sqrt{0.20}=19.68\ \text{cm/s}=0.1968\ \text{m/s}

This is within the usual 0.1-0.4 m/s range, so deposited sediment is not re-suspended.

Step 2: Cross-section and width

Assume a flow depth H=2.4H=2.4 m in the settling zone (sediment storage is extra).

B=Q′vH=5.00.1968×2.4=10.59 mB=\frac{Q'}{vH}=\frac{5.0}{0.1968\times2.4}=10.59\ \text{m}

Provide n=2n=2 chambers so that one can be flushed while the others work: b=B/n=5.29b=B/n=5.29 m each, adopt 5.5 m.

Step 3: Length without turbulence

L0=vHw=0.1968×2.40.0600=7.9 mL_0=\frac{vH}{w}=\frac{0.1968\times2.4}{0.0600}=7.9\ \text{m}

Step 4: Effect of turbulence

Turbulence reduces the effective fall velocity: w′=w−αw'=w-\alpha, with α=0.132 v/H\alpha=0.132\,v/\sqrt{H}.

α=0.132×0.19682.4=0.0168 m/sw′=0.0600−0.0168=0.0432 m/sL=vHw′=0.1968×2.40.0432=10.9 m\begin{aligned} \alpha&=\frac{0.132\times0.1968}{\sqrt{2.4}}=0.0168\ \text{m/s}\\ w'&=0.0600-0.0168=0.0432\ \text{m/s}\\ L&=\frac{vH}{w'}=\frac{0.1968\times2.4}{0.0432}=10.9\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Adopted dimensions

ItemValue
Flow velocity vv0.197 m/s
Settling depth HH2.4 m (plus about 1.0 m sediment storage in the hopper)
Number of chambers2
Width of each chamber5.5 m
Length of settling zone15 m
Length/width ratio2.7
Inlet transitiongradual, with guide vanes (side slope not steeper than about 1:5)

Total volume of water in the basin ≈396\approx 396 m³.

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
 inlet          settling zone (depth H)      outlet
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  WL
 \    --->   --->   --->   --->   --->   --->  |
  \  ______________________________________   | weir
   \/   sediment storage / hopper slope 1:30 \__|__ to headrace
          flush gate -> flushing channel -> river

Flushing arrangement: the floor of each chamber slopes about 1:30-1:50 to a longitudinal flushing channel with a flushing gate at the downstream end. Flushing velocity of at least 3 m/s is kept in the channel; the chamber to be flushed is closed at the inlet, drained and flushed to the river, while the other chambers continue to supply the plant.

Comparison

CaseEffective fall velocityLength of settling zone
Without turbulencew=0.060w=0.060 m/sL0=7.87L_0=7.87 m
With turbulencew′=0.0432w'=0.0432 m/sL=10.92L=10.92 m

Turbulence increases the length by 39%; width (10.59 m in total) and depth are unchanged. For periodic flushing, sediment storage depth is added below the settling zone and each chamber is flushed in turn.

Answer: 2 chambers, each about 5.5 m wide x 15 m long x 2.4 m deep (settling zone) with v=0.197v=0.197 m/s.

  • 2078 Bhadra · 10 marks

Design a settling basin (i) with intermittent flushing (ii) continuous flushing for a hydroelectric plant by using the simple settling theory. The design discharge of the plant is 5 m³/s and depth of the basin is 3.20 m. Take w = 2.5 cm/s and λ = 1.5. Compare and justify the result. Assume 15% flushing discharge and efficiency = 90%.

Answer

Given: Q=5Q=5 m³/s, depth H=3.2H=3.2 m, w=0.025w=0.025 m/s, λ=1.5\lambda=1.5 (this coefficient gives the required trap efficiency of about 90% with turbulence), flushing discharge 15% in the continuous case. Assume a horizontal velocity of v=0.25v=0.25 m/s (within 0.2-0.4 m/s). Simple settling theory: A=λQ/wA=\lambda Q/w.

(i) Intermittent flushing (Q=5Q=5 m³/s)

A=λQw=1.5×50.025=300 m2,B=QvH=50.25×3.2=6.25 m,L=AB=48.0 mA=\frac{\lambda Q}{w}=\frac{1.5\times5}{0.025}=300\ \text{m}^2,\qquad B=\frac{Q}{vH}=\frac{5}{0.25\times3.2}=6.25\ \text{m},\qquad L=\frac{A}{B}=48.0\ \text{m}

Provide two chambers of 3.5 m x 48 m so that one works while the other is being flushed. Sediment storage is also added (about 1 m) because the sediment stays in the basin between flushes.

(ii) Continuous flushing (Q′=1.15×5=5.75Q'=1.15\times5=5.75 m³/s)

A=1.5×5.750.025=345 m2,B=5.750.25×3.2=7.19 m,L=AB=48.0 mA=\frac{1.5\times5.75}{0.025}=345\ \text{m}^2,\qquad B=\frac{5.75}{0.25\times3.2}=7.19\ \text{m},\qquad L=\frac{A}{B}=48.0\ \text{m}

Two chambers of 3.6 m x 48 m. The settled sediment drops continuously into a hopper and is removed by the flushing water of 0.75 m³/s.

Comparison and justification

ItemIntermittentContinuous
Design flow5.00 m³/s5.75 m³/s
Surface area300 m²345 m²
Width (total)6.25 m7.19 m
Length48.0 m48.0 m
Sediment storageneeded (1 m)not needed
Water lossnone during working15% of flow
Operationbasin must be taken out and flusheduninterrupted

The length is the same (L=λvH/wL=\lambda vH/w) while the continuous basin is 15% wider because it carries 15% more water. The continuous basin needs no storage volume, no gate operation and no interruption, but it consumes 0.75 m³/s water all the time; the intermittent basin needs no flushing water except when flushing, but it needs two chambers and storage. For a small plant with little spare water, intermittent flushing is justified; for a plant with silt-laden water and automatic operation, continuous flushing is better.

Answer: (i) 2 chambers of about 3.5 m x 48 m; (ii) 2 chambers of about 3.6 m x 48 m, at a depth of 3.2 m.

  • 2081 Baishakh · 8+2 marks

Design a settling basin for particle size = 6 mm, sp. gravity = 2.65, absolute viscosity = 1.34 gm/cm-s, temperature of water = 20°C, discharge = 12 m³/s. Calculate the depth of sediment assuming concentration is 5000 ppm. Assume 15% flushing discharge and performance coefficient of Hazen = 0.16. Draw a neat sketch of plan and section.

Answer

Given: particle diameter d=6d=6 mm =0.6=0.6 cm, s=2.65s=2.65, μ=1.34\mu=1.34 g/cm·s, T=20∘T=20^\circC, Q=12Q=12 m³/s, concentration 5000 ppm (5 kg/m³), flushing discharge 15%, Hazen's performance coefficient n=0.16n=0.16.

Assumptions: required trap efficiency η=90%\eta=90\%; sediment bulk density 1325 kg/m³ (packing factor 0.5 of 2650 kg/m³); the basin is flushed every 1 hour; flow depth H=2H=2 m; L/B=4L/B=4.

Step 1: Fall velocity (Stokes, with the data given)

w=g d2(ρs−ρ)18μ=981×0.62×(2.65−1)18×1.34=24.16 cm/s=0.2416 m/sw=\frac{g\,d^2(\rho_s-\rho)}{18\mu}=\frac{981\times0.6^2\times(2.65-1)}{18\times1.34}=24.16\ \text{cm/s}=0.2416\ \text{m/s}

Step 2: Design flow with flushing

Q′=1.15×12=13.8 m3/sQ'=1.15\times12=13.8\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}

Step 3: Surface area (Hazen)

Hazen's relation for the fraction removed:   1−η=[1+nw AQ′]−1/n\;1-\eta=\left[1+n\dfrac{w\,A}{Q'}\right]^{-1/n}, so

A=Q′n w[(1−η)−n−1]=13.80.16×0.2416[(0.1)−0.16−1]=159.0 m2A=\frac{Q'}{n\,w}\left[(1-\eta)^{-n}-1\right]=\frac{13.8}{0.16\times0.2416}\left[(0.1)^{-0.16}-1\right]=159.0\ \text{m}^2

Step 4: Plan size

B=A4=6.31 m,L=4B=25.2 m⇒ adopt 7 m×28 m×2 m deepB=\sqrt{\frac{A}{4}}=6.31\ \text{m},\qquad L=4B=25.2\ \text{m}\quad\Rightarrow\ \text{adopt }7\ \text{m}\times28\ \text{m}\times2\ \text{m deep}

Step 5: Depth of sediment

Concentration 50005000 ppm =5=5 kg/m³. Sediment trapped per hour:

M=η C Q′ t=0.9×5×13.8×3600=223560 kgM=\eta\,C\,Q'\,t=0.9\times5\times13.8\times3600=223560\ \text{kg} Vs=M1325=168.7 m3,hs=VsA=168.7159.0=1.06 mV_s=\frac{M}{1325}=168.7\ \text{m}^3,\qquad h_s=\frac{V_s}{A}=\frac{168.7}{159.0}=1.06\ \text{m}

So the sediment accumulates to about 1.06 m depth in one hour; therefore a hopper depth of at least 1.2 m is provided and the basin must be flushed at least once every hour (or continuously).

PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river

Answer: basin about 7 m x 28 m x 2 m (plus 1.2 m hopper); sediment depth about 1.06 m per hour of operation.

Note: the viscosity 1.34 g/cm·s and the 6 mm size are used exactly as given; Stokes' law is not strictly valid for 6 mm particles, so the fall velocity is only indicative.

  • 2071 Chaitra · 8 marks

Design the settling basin from the particle size and concentration approach and calculate the trap efficiency from the following data (refer to Figure 3 and 4: Camp's diagram; fall velocity of quartz spheres in water after Rouse): design discharge = 80 m³/s; number of basins = 2; installed capacity of the plant = 110 MW; water temperature = 12°C; particle size to be removed = 0.2 mm; Manning's constant (n) = 0.01; flushing discharge = 1 m³/s (if flushing system is continuous). Assume other necessary data if needed. If the flushing system is changed to intermittent with a single basin, what are the changes? Describe with suitable reason.

Answer

Given: Q=80Q=80 m³/s; 2 basins; installed capacity 110 MW (so a high-head Pelton plant); T=12∘T=12^\circC; particle size d=0.2d=0.2 mm; continuous flushing of 1 m³/s.

The head follows from P=ρgQHηP=\rho g Q H\eta with η=0.88\eta=0.88: H=110×1069810×80×0.88=159H=\dfrac{110\times10^6}{9810\times80\times0.88}=159 m. At this head the particles above 0.2 mm must be removed.

Assumptions: fall velocity of a 0.2 mm quartz sphere at 12°C (Rouse's curve) w≈2.2w\approx2.2 cm/s; flow depth Hs=5H_s=5 m; design trap efficiency 90%; Manning's n=0.01n=0.01 is only needed for the flushing channel.

Step 1: Particle-size approach, design flow

Q′=80+1=81 m3/s(40.5 m3/s per basin)Q'=80+1=81\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}\quad(40.5\ \text{m}^3/\text{s per basin})

Step 2: Velocity and size

Camp's velocity: v=440.2=19.68v=44\sqrt{0.2}=19.68 cm/s =0.1968=0.1968 m/s.

Btotal=Q′vHs=810.1968×5=82.3 m ⇒ b=82.32=41.2 m per basinB_{total}=\frac{Q'}{vH_s}=\frac{81}{0.1968\times5}=82.3\ \text{m}\ \Rightarrow\ b=\frac{82.3}{2}=41.2\ \text{m per basin}

Step 3: Length (Camp-Vetter turbulence approach)

Turbulence reduces the fall velocity: α=0.132v/Hs=0.0116\alpha=0.132v/\sqrt{H_s}=0.0116 m/s, w′=0.022−0.0116=0.0104w'=0.022-0.0116=0.0104 m/s.

Lideal=vHsw′=94.7 mL_{ideal}=\frac{vH_s}{w'}=94.7\ \text{m}

For a trap efficiency η\eta, Vetter's relation is η=1−exp⁡(−w′LvHs)\eta=1-\exp\left(-\dfrac{w'L}{vH_s}\right). For η=90%\eta=90\%:

L=ln⁡(10)×94.7=218.2 m ⇒ adopt L=220 mL=\ln(10)\times94.7=218.2\ \text{m}\ \Rightarrow\ \text{adopt }L=220\ \text{m}

Step 4: Trap efficiency of the adopted basin

η=1−exp⁡(−0.0104×2200.1968×5)=90.2%\eta=1-\exp\left(-\frac{0.0104\times220}{0.1968\times5}\right)=90.2\%

Particles smaller than 0.2 mm have a lower fall velocity and are trapped with a lower efficiency, found in the same way with their own ww.

Step 5: Sediment and flushing

The sediment trapped drops into the hoppers and leaves continuously with the 1 m³/s flushing water (0.5 m³/s per basin) through the flushing channel (slope about 1:50, n=0.01n=0.01). Provide an extra depth of about 1.0 m for the hoppers.

ItemValue (each basin)
Width42 m
Length220 m
Flow depth5 m + 1 m hopper
Velocity0.1968 m/s
Trap efficiency (0.2 mm)90.2%

If the flushing is intermittent with a single basin

  • Discharge: the flushing discharge (1 m³/s) is no longer needed, so Q′=80Q'=80 m³/s, but the whole flow passes through one basin: width B=800.1968×5=81.3B=\dfrac{80}{0.1968\times5}=81.3 m (about 82 m); the length is the same, so the structure is about twice as wide as one of the two basins.
  • Storage: the sediment is no longer removed continuously, so a sediment storage depth must be added (volume = sediment load x flushing interval / bulk density).
  • Plant stoppage: with a single basin, the plant (or the incoming water) must be stopped to flush it, or a bypass is needed; with two basins one can keep working. A single intermittent basin therefore interrupts generation during flushing unless a bypass or a storage pond is provided, and each flush needs a large discharge for a short time.
  • Efficiency: the trap efficiency during the flushing and just after is lower because of the disturbed flow and bed deposits.
PLAN (flushing gates at the downstream end)
          inlet        settling chambers      outlet
 canal   transition  +=================+   transition
 =====>  \         / |  chamber 1      | \         /===> to
         /  guide  \ +-----------------+ /  weir   \    headrace
 =====>  \  vanes  / |  chamber 2      | \         /
         /         \ +=================+ /         \
  trash-                  |  |  flush gates
  rack                    v  v  --> flushing channel --> river

Answer: 2 basins of about 42 m x 220 m x 5 m (+1 m hopper); v=0.1968v=0.1968 m/s; trap efficiency of the 0.2 mm particles about 90.2%.

  • 2073 Shrawan · 2+4 marks

What do you mean by sediment flushing in a settling basin? Briefly explain the different types of flushing systems used in hydropower in Nepal.

Answer

Sediment flushing

Sediment flushing is the removal of the sediment settled in a settling basin (desander) by opening a flushing gate and letting fast-flowing water carry the deposit out through a flushing channel or tunnel back to the river. It keeps the basin storage free so that the basin can go on trapping sediment and protects the turbines from abrasion.

Types of flushing systems used in Nepal

  1. Intermittent (periodic) flushing
    • The basin has a hopper or a sloping floor (1:20-1:50) with a flushing gate at the downstream end.
    • Sediment is allowed to accumulate for hours; then the chamber is isolated (inlet closed), drained and flushed with water of velocity of 3 m/s or more through the open gate. With two or more chambers, one works while the other is flushed.
    • Used in most Nepali RoR plants: simple, with a lower water loss in total.
  2. Continuous flushing
    • The floor has longitudinal hoppers or slots with a continuous extraction of 10-20% of the flow, which carry the sediment out all the time.
    • Examples: Bieri (slotted pipe) and Serpent systems, Dufour type; used where flushing time must be short or the sediment load is very high. It needs extra water (10-20%), and the basin must be larger.
  3. Gravity flushing / sluicing with a gate in the river bed (undersluice) is used at the headworks and gravel trap.
  4. Mechanical removal (dredging, sediment-sucking system) is used in small plants where hydraulic flushing is not possible.
  • 2070 Ashad · 3 marks

If you have allocated about 10% volume for sediment storage and the overall trapping efficiency of the settling basin is 40%, find out the frequency of flushing of the settling basin when the sediment concentration is 2000 ppm.

Answer

Given: sediment storage =10%=10\% of the basin volume VbV_b; overall trap efficiency η=40%\eta=40\%; sediment concentration C=2000C=2000 ppm =2.0=2.0 kg/m³. Assumption: the settled sediment has a bulk density of ρb=2650×0.5=1325\rho_b=2650\times0.5=1325 kg/m³ (particle density 2650 kg/m³, packing factor 0.5).

Step 1: Volume of sediment trapped per m³ of water

vs=η Cρb=0.40×2.01325=6.038×10−4 m3 of deposit per m3 of waterv_s=\frac{\eta\,C}{\rho_b}=\frac{0.40\times2.0}{1325}=6.038 \times 10^{-4}\ \text{m}^3\ \text{of deposit per m}^3\ \text{of water}

Step 2: Storage volume

Vst=0.10 VbV_{st}=0.10\,V_b

Step 3: Volume of water that can pass before the storage is full

Vw=Vstvs=0.10 Vb6.038×10−4=165.6 VbV_w=\frac{V_{st}}{v_s}=\frac{0.10\,V_b}{6.038 \times 10^{-4}}=165.6\,V_b

Step 4: Frequency of flushing

The water passes through the basin at the rate QQ, so the time between flushes is

T=VwQ=165.6 VbQ=165.6 tdT=\frac{V_w}{Q}=165.6\,\frac{V_b}{Q}=165.6\,t_d

where td=Vb/Qt_d=V_b/Q is the detention time of the basin.

So the basin should be flushed once after about 165.6 detention periods (about every 166 times the time that water takes to pass through it). For example, if the detention time is 10 minutes, then T=1656T=1656 minutes ≈27.6\approx27.6 hours (about 0.9 flushes per day); if td=5t_d=5 minutes, T≈13.8T\approx13.8 hours.

Answer: flush every ≈165.6 Vb/Q\approx165.6\,V_b/Q (about 166 detention times; e.g. about 27.6 h for a 10-minute detention time).

  • 2076 Ashwin · 4 marks

Explain various remedial measures that help to control the deposition of sediments in a RoR project.

Answer

Sediment deposition in a RoR project occurs at the intake, in the gravel trap, in the settling basin, in the headrace and in front of the weir. It is controlled by the following measures.

  1. Choice of the intake location: put the intake on the outer bank of a river bend with the sill above the river bed, so that bed load moves past.
  2. Undersluice (scouring sluice) and flushing gates in front of the intake, which are opened in the flood to flush the deposited sediment through the weir.
  3. Divide wall and curtain (skimming) wall to draw only the upper clean layer of water into the intake.
  4. Gravel trap after the intake to settle the coarse material, with a flushing gate.
  5. Settling basin (desander) with sufficient size to settle particles above the design size (0.15-0.2 mm), with a flushing system (intermittent or continuous).
  6. Flood operation rule: shut the intake during the high sediment load of the flood season or when the concentration crosses the limit.
  7. Weir pond operation: lower the pond level for sluicing during floods (drawdown flushing) so that the sediment is pushed out.
  8. Catchment treatment (afforestation, check dams, terracing, bank protection) to reduce the sediment production.
  9. Regular maintenance: dredging and cleaning of the canal and pond.

Questions from Old Question Collection (CE 704) (IOE exam papers from 2069 Chaitra to 2082 Bhadra). Answers are written for this site; check them against your class notes.

Chapter titles and hours from the IOE syllabus ↗